Grade these coaches.

#1
KingtUT

KingtUT

I reign supreme!
Joined
Dec 3, 2010
Messages
5,798
Likes
3,694
#1
On a scale of 1-10, 10 being the best, what score do you give each of these coaches? Without a whole lot of thought... here's my scores.

Saban = 10 (obviously)
Myer = 9.5
Dabo = 9
Butch Jones = 7.5
Dan Mullins = 7.6
Bob Stoops = 8.2
James Franklin = 8.2
Malzahn = 7.5
Smart = 7.4
Muschamp = 7
Mason = 6.5
Mcelwain = 7.2

Its still the off season so just play along if you'd like or just ignore it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#2
#2
Saban - 10
Meyer - 9
Dabo - 8.5
Butch - 7
Mullen - 7
B. Stoops - 9
Franklin - 8.5
Malzahn - 7
Smart - 6
Muschamp - 6.5
Mason - 7
McElwain - 6
 
#3
#3
Saban = 10
Myer = 9.5
Dabo = 9.0
Butch Jones = 7.5
Dan Mullins = 8.0
Bob Stoops = 8.5
James Franklin = 8.5
Malzahn = 8.0
Smart = 7.5
Muschamp = 7
Mason = 6.5
Mcelwain = 7.5
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#4
#4
Saban-9, Players make him great, new Dodges get good players
Myer 8, He jumped out of the bigs, claimed he was crazy
Dabo, 9, Good guy, lets his coaches coach
Butch, 8.5, People forget what a wreck he inherited, and the admission standards at UT aren't fair to him, he plays by a different set of rules thanks to jimmy cheek
Dan Mullins 8. Good solid coach, Starkville suks
James Franklin, 8, He is lucky that his Vandy past legalities haven't caught him ...yet
Malzahn, 7, Gimmicky Offense, but it works..
Smart, 8, Dude is mean and competitive, make no mistake, HE HATES UT
Muschamp, 7.5 Great D Coach, Meaner than hell, HE HATES UT
Mason, 5, Hasn't had a winning season yet, and wears fake glasses just for fashion.
McElwain, 9, Guy can coach, he would be good in the NFL... and I don't like him
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
#5
#5
Nocleats said:
Saban-9, Players make him great, new Dodges get good players
Myer 8, He jumped out of the bigs, claimed he was crazy
Dabo, 9, Good guy, lets his coaches coach
Butch, 8.5, People forget what a wreck he inherited, and the admission standards at UT aren't fair to him, he plays by a different set of rules thanks to jimmy cheek
Dan Mullins 8. Good solid coach, Starkville suks
James Franklin, 8, He is lucky that his Vandy past legalities haven't caught him ...yet
Malzahn, 7, Gimmicky Offense, but it works..
Smart, 8, Dude is mean and competitive, make no mistake, HE HATES UT
Muschamp, 7.5 Great D Coach, Meaner than hell, HE HATES UT
Mason, 5, Hasn't had a winning season yet, and wears fake glasses just for fashion.
McElwain, 9, Guy can coach, he would be good in the NFL... and I don't like him
Click to expand...


Wow, Saban = Mcelwain
:lolabove::lolabove::lolabove::lolabove:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
#6
#6
Nocleats said:
Saban-9, Players make him great, new Dodges get good players
Myer 8, He jumped out of the bigs, claimed he was crazy
Dabo, 9, Good guy, lets his coaches coach
Butch, 8.5, People forget what a wreck he inherited, and the admission standards at UT aren't fair to him, he plays by a different set of rules thanks to jimmy cheek
Dan Mullins 8. Good solid coach, Starkville suks
James Franklin, 8, He is lucky that his Vandy past legalities haven't caught him ...yet
Malzahn, 7, Gimmicky Offense, but it works..
Smart, 8, Dude is mean and competitive, make no mistake, HE HATES UT
Muschamp, 7.5 Great D Coach, Meaner than hell, HE HATES UT
Mason, 5, Hasn't had a winning season yet, and wears fake glasses just for fashion.
McElwain, 9, Guy can coach, he would be good in the NFL... and I don't like him
Click to expand...

So Butch is a better coach than Urban Meyer?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#8
#8
Saban = 10 (obviously)
Myer = 9.5
Dabo = 9
Butch Jones = 6
Dan Mullen = 7
Bob Stoops = 8
James Franklin = 7
Malzahn = 6
Smart = 6
Muschamp = 4
Mason = 4
Mcelwain = 6



Butch is about as average as average gets.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 5 people
#9
#9
Saban and Meyer are both 10s IMO. Both have won championships at multiple schools, Meyer even had Utah built up pretty good. Also I would say Meyer's coaching tree has actually been better as well for assistants taking other jobs. Fisher is the only Saban assistant to do well thus far.

Smart being rated a 7.2 is rolling on the floor laughable. What the hell has he done to be rated that highly?

Mullen and Muschamp IDK how good they would be at major schools but for their programs they're great coaches or at least have been so far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#11
#11
Saban = 10
Meyer = 9.5 (Cant give the quitter a 10)
Dabo = 9
Butch Jones = 6
Dan Mullen = 7.5
Bob Stoops = 401(k)
James Franklin = 8.5
Malzahn = 7.5
Smart = 3
Muschamp = 6
Mason = 5
SharkHumper = 7.5

I know this wont make me popular but oh well....
 
#12
#12
Saban - 10
Meyer -10
Dabo - 9
L. Jones- 6.5
Mullen - 7.5
Stoops - 8.75
Franklin - 8
Malzhan - 7
Smart - 5.5
Muschamp - 6.75
Mason - 5. 25
McElwain - 7.5
 
#13
#13
DaddyChad said:
Saban and Meyer are both 10s IMO. Both have won championships at multiple schools, Meyer even had Utah built up pretty good. Also I would say Meyer's coaching tree has actually been better as well for assistants taking other jobs. Fisher is the only Saban assistant to do well thus far.

Smart being rated a 7.2 is rolling on the floor laughable. What the hell has he done to be rated that highly?

Mullen and Muschamp IDK how good they would be at major schools but for their programs they're great coaches or at least have been so far.
Click to expand...

Muschamp lost to Georgia Southern while he was the head coach of UF. I think we know how he would fare at a major program.
 
#17
#17
fade route said:
The guy you have at 6.5 is 4-0 vs the guy you have as a 7
Click to expand...

And? Are you implying Muschamp is equal or better? Butch is undefeated vs Dantonio and Spurrier so I guess he's equal or better than them? Steve Stripling is 1-0 vs David Cutcliffe.

Also, it's 3 not 4. If you're gonna try to insult him (or whatever you attempted) you should get it right at least.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#18
#18
Satan = 10
Quitter = 9
Dabo = 9.5
Butch Jones = 7.5 honestly could be higher because he came into a dumpster fire. And if not for injuries we would have won the East last year!!!
Dan Mullins = 7
Bob Stoops = 8
James Franklin = 6.5
Malzahn = 7.5
Smart = 7 (just because of how good of a DC he was) still not sure as a HC...
Muschamp = 7.5
Mason = 6
Mcelwain = 7 -.5 for shark humping
 
#19
#19
Nocleats said:
Saban-9, Players make him great, new Dodges get good players
Myer 8, He jumped out of the bigs, claimed he was crazy
Dabo, 9, Good guy, lets his coaches coach
Butch, 8.5, People forget what a wreck he inherited, and the admission standards at UT aren't fair to him, he plays by a different set of rules thanks to jimmy cheek
Dan Mullins 8. Good solid coach, Starkville suks
James Franklin, 8, He is lucky that his Vandy past legalities haven't caught him ...yet
Malzahn, 7, Gimmicky Offense, but it works..
Smart, 8, Dude is mean and competitive, make no mistake, HE HATES UT
Muschamp, 7.5 Great D Coach, Meaner than hell, HE HATES UT
Mason, 5, Hasn't had a winning season yet, and wears fake glasses just for fashion.
McElwain, 9, Guy can coach, he would be good in the NFL... and I don't like him
Click to expand...

Do what????
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#20
#20
VolFan420 said:
Satan = 10
Quitter = 9
Dabo = 9.5
Butch Jones = 7.5 honestly could be higher because he came into a dumpster fire. And if not for injuries we would have won the East last year!!!
Dan Mullins = 7
Bob Stoops = 8
James Franklin = 6.5
Malzahn = 7.5
Smart = 7 (just because of how good of a DC he was) still not sure as a HC...
Muschamp = 7.5
Mason = 6
Mcelwain = 7 -.5 for shark humping
Click to expand...

Dabo over Myer? and Franklin a 6.5? C'MON MAN!!
 
#21
#21
KingtUT said:
On a scale of 1-10, 10 being the best, what score do you give each of these coaches? Without a whole lot of thought... here's my scores.

Saban = 10 (obviously)
Myer = 9.5
Dabo = 9
Butch Jones = 7.5
Dan Mullins = 7.6
Bob Stoops = 8.2
James Franklin = 8.2
Malzahn = 7.5
Smart = 7.4
Muschamp = 7
Mason = 6.5
Mcelwain = 7.2

Its still the off season so just play along if you'd like or just ignore it.
Click to expand...

Saban= 10
Meyer= 9.5
Dabo= 9
Stoops= 8.5
Franklin= 8
Mullen= 7.5
Malzahan= 7
Mason= 7
Muschamp= 6.5
Butch= 6
Butter teeth= 5.8
Smart= 5.5
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#23
#23
Saban - 10
Meyer - 9
B. Stoops - 9
Dabo - 8.5
Mullen - 7.5
Franklin - 7.5
Malzahn - 7.5
Butch - 7
Muschamp - 7
Mason - 7
Smart - 6
McElwain - 6
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top