You're first sentence corroborates my statement. We didn't play backups. Why? Because the talent drop off was steep.
It was not a dropoff of talent it was more experience. We have a very very young team at WR the guys we played were all upperclassmen.... not only that CJH has never played a deep rotation at WR.. the only reason we ever go past 5 guys is injuries and blowouts.. period. In his time at UT Squirrel white is the only exception to that rule... he is the only underclassman to ever get significant snaps as a freshman and that was mostly because of blowouts. Every year he has been here the WR rotation is made up of Juniors and Seniors sans injuries and Squirrel except 2021 when he literally had nothing but underclassmen as backups.
In order WR's who caught 10+ passes
2021 Tillman, Jones, Payton (inj), Hyatt (soph)
2022 Hyatt, McCoy, Keyton, White, TIllman(inj)... Keyton got snaps because Tillman was out) white backed up Hyatt.
2023 Squirrel, Keyton (in for McCoy), Thornton(inj), McCoy (inj), Nimrod(backup slot), Webb (in for Thornton)
2024 Thornton, Mccoy, White, Brazzell, Nimrod (injury snaps for the main 4 lol)
Since CJH has been here only 3 freshmen have ever caught 10+ passes. The only one that was 'productive' was white at 30 which sounds super impressive until you realize it happened in 8 games all blowouts (9 of his catches came in the bowl game). Almost all his catches 21 of 30, and both TD's, came from Joe Milton. If the team is healthy he runs a 4 man rotation at WR. Even in times we had mass injuries he only goes 5-6. On any year you go past the first 4 and anyone else got in it was because of injuries. If Tillman hadn't been injured Squirrel does not get half the regular season snaps he got his freshman year and ends up with 20 and 1TD instead of 30 and 2. Regular season he caught 12 passes and 2 TD's from Milton and 9 passes from Hendon. I will admit Hendon used him as a PI cheat code though.
Bank this, outside of injuries and blowouts we will not play more than 4 WR's plus Boo this year regularly. If we bring in another transfer WR it means Staley or Jefferson gets bumped down to the under 10 catches club. Which is why I don't think we take another WR in portal its more likely to be a CB or DL. So the WR looks like this.
Brazzell
Matthews
Staley?
Jefferson
Boo
I just realized something researching this 3 of our walk-on tight ends including Charlie Browder hit the portal.. Makes sense with what we have coming in. but dang.