Don't forget Atkins and White are HOF'ers. I'd say both those guys are "superstar" worthy.There are only a few superstars relatively speaking. Manning was our last one. We have a had a bunch that were damn good, made all pro and maybe several pro bowls. Witten was damn good, but probably not a superstar. Should be HOF. I guess maybe HOF status could be synonymous with "superstar". Really though, superstar is saved for someone with multiple MVPs. There are very few. Like I said, Manning
Crazy thread.
Don't forget Atkins and White are HOF'ers. I'd say both those guys are "superstar" worthy.
Eric Berry is on the list.Yeah, of course. I said Manning was the last one we have had
Forgot about Berry, but I am not sure he would have ever been superstar status. He was definitely one of the top 5 players in the league at his position.Eric Berry is on the list.
Nominated for the 2026 NFL Hall of Fame class (1st year he is eligible) and likely to be in on the first ballot.
Trey Smith may make it on the list someday too.
As far as next 'Superstar", I don't think he's yet on this team.
There are a couple on the team now that will be great, but not sure they will be HOF / Superstar level...likely the closest will be Brazell or Josephs.
Depending on what situation they get drafted into, could turn out as 'Superstars'.
Forgot about Berry, but I am not sure he would have ever been superstar status. He was definitely one of the top 5 players in the league at his position.
Yeah - let's start with the definition of 'Superstar".I guess the question is what do you define as superstar? Is it someone that could be the face of their team or the league or is it someone that is top of their position and considered among the greats to play that position.
