Best VFL in the NFL every year wince 1950

[golfballvol]

Best UT NFL Player by year:

2025 - Trey Smith

2024 - Trey Smith

2023 - Trey Smith

2022 - Alvin Kamara

2021 - Alvin Kamara

2020 - Alvin Kamara

2019 - Alvin Kamara

2018 - Alvin Kamara

2017 - Alvin Kamara

2016 - Eric Berry

2015 - Eric Berry

2014 - Peyton Manning

2013 - Peyton Manning

2012 - Peyton Manning

2011 - Arian Foster

2010 - Arian Foster

2009 - Peyton Manning

2008 - Peyton Manning

2007 - Albert Haynesworth

2006 - Peyton Manning

2005 - Peyton Manning

2004 - Peyton Manning

2003 - Peyton Manning

2002 - Peyton Manning

2001 - Al Wilson

2000 - Peyton Manning

1999 - Peyton Manning

1998 - Reggie White

1997 - Reggie White

1996 - Dale Carter

1995 - Reggie White

1994 - Reggie White

1993 - Reggie White

1992 - Reggie White

1991 - Reggie White

1990 - Reggie White

1989 - Reggie White

1988 - Reggie White

1987 - Reggie White

1986 - Reggie White

1985 - Reggie White

1984 - Bill Bates

1983 - Stanley Morgan

1982 - Roland James

1981 - Stanley Morgan

1980 - Stanley Morgan

1979 - Stanley Morgan

1978 - Stanley Morgan

1977 - Eddie Brown

1976 - Eddie Brown

1975 - Jack Reynolds

1974 - Jack Reynolds

1973 - Jack Reynolds

1972 - Mike Lucci

1971 - Mike Lucci

1970 - Paul Naumoff

1969 - Steve DeLong

1968 - Doug Atkins

1967 - Mike Stratton

1966 - Mike Stratton

1965 - Doug Atkins

1964 - Mike Stratton

1963 - Doug Atkins

1962 - Doug Atkins

1961 - Doug Atkins

1960 - Doug Atkins

1959 - Doug Atkins

1958 - Doug Atkins

1957 - Doug Atkins

1956 - Bert Rechinar

1955 - Jack Stroud

1954 - Bert Rechinar

1953 - Paul Lipscomb

1952 - Paul Lipscomb

1951 - Paul Lipscomb

1950 - Paul Lipscomb

 

[hbvol1982]

Nice list!

 

[golfballvol]

Nice list!

Thanks

 

[BernardKingGOAT]

Best UT NFL Player by year:

2025 - Trey Smith

2024 - Trey Smith

2023 - Trey Smith

2022 - Alvin Kamara

2021 - Alvin Kamara

2020 - Alvin Kamara

2019 - Alvin Kamara

2018 - Alvin Kamara

2017 - Alvin Kamara

2016 - Eric Berry

2015 - Eric Berry

2014 - Peyton Manning

2013 - Peyton Manning

2012 - Peyton Manning

2011 - Arian Foster

2010 - Arian Foster

2009 - Peyton Manning

2008 - Peyton Manning

2007 - Albert Haynesworth

2006 - Peyton Manning

2005 - Peyton Manning

2004 - Peyton Manning

2003 - Peyton Manning

2002 - Peyton Manning

2001 - Al Wilson

2000 - Peyton Manning

1999 - Peyton Manning

1998 - Reggie White

1997 - Reggie White

1996 - Dale Carter

1995 - Reggie White

1994 - Reggie White

1993 - Reggie White

1992 - Reggie White

1991 - Reggie White

1990 - Reggie White

1989 - Reggie White

1988 - Reggie White

1987 - Reggie White

1986 - Reggie White

1985 - Reggie White

1984 - Bill Bates

1983 - Stanley Morgan

1982 - Roland James

1981 - Stanley Morgan

1980 - Stanley Morgan

1979 - Stanley Morgan

1978 - Stanley Morgan

1977 - Eddie Brown

1976 - Eddie Brown

1975 - Jack Reynolds

1974 - Jack Reynolds

1973 - Jack Reynolds

1972 - Mike Lucci

1971 - Mike Lucci

1970 - Paul Naumoff

1969 - Steve DeLong

1968 - Doug Atkins

1967 - Mike Stratton

1966 - Mike Stratton

1965 - Doug Atkins

1964 - Mike Stratton

1963 - Doug Atkins

1962 - Doug Atkins

1961 - Doug Atkins

1960 - Doug Atkins

1959 - Doug Atkins

1958 - Doug Atkins

1957 - Doug Atkins

1956 - Bert Rechinar

1955 - Jack Stroud

1954 - Bert Rechinar

1953 - Paul Lipscomb

1952 - Paul Lipscomb

1951 - Paul Lipscomb

1950 - Paul Lipscomb

Is that your list?

Charlie Garner needs to have at least one year in there

 

[golfballvol]

Is that your list?

Charlie Garner needs to have at least one year in there

yeah my list. Which year for garner?

 

[BernardKingGOAT]

yeah my list. Which year for garner?

2002

 

[golfballvol]

2002

Manning was a pro bowler that year and garner was not

 

[BernardKingGOAT]

Manning was a pro bowler that year and garner was not

Garner was All Pro that year and was a big reason the Raiders made the Super Bowl. Not sure why he wasn't a pro bowler, which isn't as significant as All Pro

@golfballvol edit: Garner opted out of 2002 Pro Bowl. His replacement was none other than Travis Henry

 

[Action_1505]

Jamal Lewis deserves one year in there wasn’t he Offensive MVP

 

[UTwild82]

Peyton and Reggie kind of knock out some deserving folks, but when you're arguably the best to ever play in the league at your position, that's going to knock some deserving folks out. (EDIT not trying to start another Peyton v Tom debate).

I believe Carl Pickens had most, if not all, Bengals receiving records when he retired and played in 95 and 96 Pro Bowls, but was he better than Reggie or Dale those years? Probably not.

03 Jamal vs Peyton is a coin flip. 2000 yards rushing vs co-MVP. I THINK I'd lean Jamal bc 2000 yards rushing has only been done 9 times, but it's hard to argue against league MVP.

MAN we used to send some DUDES to the league.

 

[TheycallmePops]

I winced just thinking about it

 

[ZZ13]

Peyton and Reggie kind of knock out some deserving folks, but when you're arguably the best to ever play in the league at your position, that's going to knock some deserving folks out. (EDIT not trying to start another Peyton v Tom debate).

I believe Carl Pickens had most, if not all, Bengals receiving records when he retired and played in 95 and 96 Pro Bowls, but was he better than Reggie or Dale those years? Probably not.

03 Jamal vs Peyton is a coin flip. 2000 yards rushing vs co-MVP. I THINK I'd lean Jamal bc 2000 yards rushing has only been done 9 times, but it's hard to argue against league MVP.

MAN we used to send some DUDES to the league.

That year he also set the then record of 275 yards rushing in one game, against Cleveland (broken by Adrian Peterson by 1 yard I think a year or two later). I'm voting Jamal for that year.