When your QB has gone off for 506 yards and 3 TDs, only threw one bad pass down the sideline all game, and hasn’t been sacked all game, you don’t have to - honestly you shouldn’t - go for two in the first OT.
You’re easily able to keep up with them at this point, go into another OT period where you’ll almost certainly score again and let them mess up first.
I get people like the gutsiness of “go for 2 after the first OT”, but this was just such a wrong scenario for it here.