Before I express my opinions on this, know that I gave this new band a chance and saw them live in Mizzou. I'm not some close-minded jerk who hates the thought of change.
However, with Alice in Chains, it's a huge exception. Aside from the fact that replacing a voice like Layne Staley's is a difficult task, I honestly can't stand DuVall's nasal twist on the signature AiC wail.
On its own, the record's okay, but as an AiC album, it's slow and weak... that's just my 2 cents.
This is also coming from someone who loved their debut record and can't go a day without listening to Real Thing, so I'm a little biased on replacing the tortured howl Layne possessed.