Athlon Ranks College Football's Top 25 Uniforms in 2013

#1

Volosaurus rex

Doctorate in Volology
Joined
Dec 2, 2009
Messages
6,036
Likes
4,244
#1
Here is the link to an article that is certain to stir debate between partisans on both sides of the traditionalist vs. alternative uniform divide: Ranking College Football's Top 25 Uniforms in 2013 | AthlonSports.com .

As a staunch Tennessee loyalist and traditionalist, I adamantly disagree with their ranking of our uniform (20th) although the fact that it is authored by someone who works for a company headquartered in Nashville may have something to do with it. I certainly don’t consider the bland uniforms of Penn State to be the best in college football as this author does. Nevertheless, a number of general observations are made in this article with which I wholeheartedly agree. With respect to our uniforms, the author states:

“The color is gaudy for sure but what makes Tennessee's uniforms stylish are their simplicity. The two-tone white and orange combination has classically survived decades of uniform tweaks. No matter how many bad alternates crop up (like these ugly duds [with a link provided to the jerseys worn for the 2009 South Carolina game]), the Vols always return to their simple home orange tops and traditional white pants (shown). With the addition of the new-er orange pants, this get-up has only gotten better.”

With respect to Georgia’s uniform, the author states: “The black and red stripes on the pants add the perfect amount of color and the ordinary and classic tops and helmets have worked for decades. And when it comes to black alternates, a team with black in its primary color scheme can always pull it off better than those who have to force it (looking at you Tennessee, Arkansas, Kentucky, Texas A&M and Mississippi State).”

In comments pertaining to Alabama’s uniforms, he observes that “Programs like Texas, Oklahoma, Penn State and Alabama should never change their simple, classic and traditional style.” He observes, similarly, with regard to Oklahoma that “The Crimson and the Cream are a perfect example of an old-school uniform with no frills, quirky piping or silly helmets. Some teams should never go down the Oregon/Maryland path of dressing and the Sooners are one of them

The same fundamental message is repeated with respect to Nebraska: “The Huskers' road uniforms might be the best in the nation. The helmet will never go out of style and it hasn't been changed in what seems like a century.” As for Michigan, “The Maize and Blue color combination has been wildly popular for decades and the no-frills style will never be changed (hopefully). These uniforms stand out as some of the best in the history of the game and it's great that a school holds on to its tradition by keeping it simple.”

The proverbial bottom line is that traditional powers--a category that includes Tennessee, regardless of what we have endured the last five years--possess deeply entrenched identities and strong brand recognition. They do not need to constantly reinvent themselves stylistically for the sake of enhancing their profile.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#2
#2
Great summary of the article. I liked that the article didn't just rate because of looks but also tradition.

Also wanted to say I love how you format your posts. They're really well put together :hi:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#5
#5
I agree with most. I personally never liked Iowa (looks like they think they are the steelers) ,Auburns or BYU.
 
#7
#7
Well, the fact that Tennessee's uniforms aren't ranked no. 1 automatically calls into question the accuracy of the article but I cited it because of certain general principles referenced therein, ones with which I do agree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#11
#11
Tennessee should be boosted, not docked, for wearing the black uniforms against South Carolina.
 
#14
#14
I think our white on white uniforms are about as good as it gets. I hate the orange pants.

I like Texas A&M's uniforms and Ole Miss' blue jerseys as well.
 
#16
#16
Here is the link to an article that is certain to stir debate between partisans on both sides of the traditionalist vs. alternative uniform divide: Ranking College Football's Top 25 Uniforms in 2013 | AthlonSports.com .

As a staunch Tennessee loyalist and traditionalist, I adamantly disagree with their ranking of our uniform (20th) although the fact that it is authored by someone who works for a company headquartered in Nashville may have something to do with it. I certainly don’t consider the bland uniforms of Penn State to be the best in college football as this author does. Nevertheless, a number of general observations are made in this article with which I wholeheartedly agree. With respect to our uniforms, the author states:

“The color is gaudy for sure but what makes Tennessee's uniforms stylish are their simplicity. The two-tone white and orange combination has classically survived decades of uniform tweaks. No matter how many bad alternates crop up (like these ugly duds [with a link provided to the jerseys worn for the 2009 South Carolina game]), the Vols always return to their simple home orange tops and traditional white pants (shown). With the addition of the new-er orange pants, this get-up has only gotten better.”

With respect to Georgia’s uniform, the author states: “The black and red stripes on the pants add the perfect amount of color and the ordinary and classic tops and helmets have worked for decades. And when it comes to black alternates, a team with black in its primary color scheme can always pull it off better than those who have to force it (looking at you Tennessee, Arkansas, Kentucky, Texas A&M and Mississippi State).”

In comments pertaining to Alabama’s uniforms, he observes that “Programs like Texas, Oklahoma, Penn State and Alabama should never change their simple, classic and traditional style.” He observes, similarly, with regard to Oklahoma that “The Crimson and the Cream are a perfect example of an old-school uniform with no frills, quirky piping or silly helmets. Some teams should never go down the Oregon/Maryland path of dressing and the Sooners are one of them

The same fundamental message is repeated with respect to Nebraska: “The Huskers' road uniforms might be the best in the nation. The helmet will never go out of style and it hasn't been changed in what seems like a century.” As for Michigan, “The Maize and Blue color combination has been wildly popular for decades and the no-frills style will never be changed (hopefully). These uniforms stand out as some of the best in the history of the game and it's great that a school holds on to its tradition by keeping it simple.”

The proverbial bottom line is that traditional powers--a category that includes Tennessee, regardless of what we have endured the last five years--possess deeply entrenched identities and strong brand recognition. They do not need to constantly reinvent themselves stylistically for the sake of enhancing their profile.

Any "best uni" list with PSU at the top is bogus. Off the top of my head, I'd say in no particular order: Notre Dame, UGA, LSU, Michigan, Iowa, Michigan St., Auburn, Florida, Clemson, some Oregon.
 
#19
#19
Any "best uni" list with PSU at the top is bogus. Off the top of my head, I'd say in no particular order: Notre Dame, UGA, LSU, Michigan, Iowa, Michigan St., Auburn, Florida, Clemson, some Oregon.

As much as I despise UGA, their unis are sharp, especially the road whites with the silver britches.

Alabama, Auburn and LSU are clean and classic. LSU should wear the purple at home more often imo.

UF's unis are getting a slight tweak this season with bigger numbers, standardizing on the font used in our end zones and FLORIDA logo. I hate our all blue unis...we look like the Fightin' Blueberries. Given how we play in orange jerseys lately, I'd be okay with using them in a bon fire.
 
#21
#21
Home Jerseys: Notre Dame, UGA, LSU (purple), USC, UCLA, Michigan, PSU, Alabama, Ole Miss, Iowa

Road: Auburn, Bama, Tennessee (white pants only), Oklahoma, Stanford, Nebraska
 
#23
#23
Any team that has donned the awful Nike Pro-Combat jerseys should be taken off this list. If he claims to have Penn State to be the best, even though they look like they're wearing scout team uniforms, there's no way Tennessee is 20th. Not that accurate of an article, but his reasoning behind some of his arguments are OK.
 
#24
#24
I completely agree with arguments against Penn State's bland uniforms being ranked no. 1. There is, of course, no such thing as "accuracy" when it comes to something as subjective as taste in uniforms. I posted this article mainly as a counterpoint to staunch advocates of alternate uniforms. I agree with the general premise advocated by this author that, for traditional powers, ones with deeply entrenched identities and strong brand recognition, there is absolutely nothing to be gained by following the Oregon trend toward outlandish uniforms.
 

VN Store



Back
Top