Best Tennessee Player That Became A MLB Star Tournament

[NO SIR EEE]

I figured this might be something fun to do to pass the time over the days. Poll is posted, you have 4 votes in the 1st round, that'll will allow you to vote for each matchup. We'll go all the way through to see who everyone votes. Final 4 will be on Monday, Championship will be on Tuesday. Vote Away. It's Bracket format. You can use 4 votes, vote for each matchup listed below.

R.A. Dickey vs Luke Hochevar

Todd Helton vs J.P. Arencibia

Phil Garner vs Zack Godley

Rick Honeycutt vs Yan Gomes

 

[chuckiepoo]

Did not realize I had four votes and it was a bracket format. I cast a vote for Todd.

 

[txbo]

Did not realize I had four votes and it was a bracket format. I cast a vote for Todd.

Yep, I screwed up too.

 

[NO SIR EEE]

Sorry fellas, worded it a little better.

 

[jbeeman85]

Dickey
Helton
Godley
Gomes

 

[StarRaider]

R.A. Dickey vs Luke Hochevar - The 2012 Cy Young Award Winner is the choice

Todd Helton vs J.P. Arencibia - Todd (like Elvis, last name not required)

Phil Garner vs Zack Godley - Scrap Iron from Jeff City.

Rick Honeycutt vs Yan Gomes - The All American with the 1976 SEC batting average title

 

[MAD]

R.A. Dickey vs Luke Hochevar - The 2012 Cy Young Award Winner is the choice

Todd Helton vs J.P. Arencibia - Todd (like Elvis, last name not required)

Phil Garner vs Zack Godley - Scrap Iron from Jeff City.

Rick Honeycutt vs Yan Gomes - The All American with the 1976 SEC batting average title

Todd 31
Everyone else combined 25

 

[StarRaider]

Funniest Tennessee Player that impersonates Tim Kurkjian (J.P. needs some luv in this thread)

 

[MAD]

Funniest Tennessee Player that impersonates Tim Kurkjian (J.P. needs some luv in this thread)

This is hilarious

 

[golfballs]

I voted before I read the instructions on the poll

 

[Volunteer08]

I gotta say it comes down to two. Helton - was one of the best at his craft lots of long-term accolades. R A Dickey another best at his craft winning the cy young award although his success may not be defined as sustained. I don’t think it’s close to those two, but if I had to pick a third I’d throw in Honeycutt because it means a lot to be a player and then a coach.

 

[Volunteer08]

I gotta say it comes down to two. Helton - was one of the best at his craft lots of long-term accolades. R A Dickey another best at his craft winning the cy young award although his success may not be defined as sustained. I don’t think it’s close to those two, but if I had to pick a third I’d throw in Honeycutt because it means a lot to be a player and then a coach.

Anddddd I forgot about Garner lol

 

[Buzzbait]

Just go ahead and narrow it down to Garner vs Helton, with apologies to Dickey.