If I have to pick, I'd probably go with a near tie between the EA Show and Josh and Swain. I like hearing the thoughts of former players combined with hosts that can guide the conversations. The other shows, both the podcasts and the Youtube stuff, they don't really do much for me. If a show is dudes talking about sports, but there's no unique insight or value to the conversation, I don't care for it very much. Especially when the hosts are either too biased or too informal.
Also, this poll reminds me of how much I miss Sportstalk in the afternoons. That show always had solid, grounded commentary, with a good balance of observations and statistics to keep things moving. It had a good pace. Whatever that show is that replaced it, man ... pfew, it is rough stuff. I tuned in once and, after hearing fifteen minutes of car commercials, some guy was on there telling me to close my eyes and "picture it," with the "it" being Joe Milton's Heisman campaign. Then the dude went on about believing it could happen. Just - wow. Wow. That was it for me. I don't even listen after Josh and Swain go off the air anymore.