BREAKING NEWS- TONY MCDANIEL

#1

BeltwayVol

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2005
Messages
1,441
Likes
4
#1
Well, I received an update on my cellphone today that the Knox News had "obtained" a video of Tony McDaniel, punching a Tennessee student in the face.

It was unclear to me as to whether this was the previous basketball incident for which Tony is already suspended the first two games, or a NEW incident.

If anyone has any news on this, please let us know.
 
#3
#3
UPDATE- It was the OLDER incident....

A video obtained by the News Sentinel clearly shows Tennessee junior defensive tackle Tony McDaniel punching UT student Edward Goodrich during a pickup basketball game Jan. 12 at the UT recreation center.


Goodrich was punched after a group of basketball players collided underneath the basket.

McDaniel immediately walked away after throwing the punch. Goodrich was motionless for almost a minute before any other participants tended to him.

Goodrich, who said he was knocked unconscious, said when he watched the tape that it appeared other UT football players stood around him and laughed at him. It is unclear from the tape if that is the case. McDaniel’s attorney Don Bosch strongly denied that claim.

Two participants in the game stood over Goodrich and looked at him, one dribbling a basketball, but their intentions are unclear. Although Goodrich said other UT athletes were present, none of the participants in the game are identifiable.

McDaniel made a deal with prosecutors and was ultimately convicted with a misdemeanor this week. McDaniel was sentenced to 11 months and 29 days in jail but placed on immediate probation and is not expected to serve any jail time.

McDaniel was retroactively suspended for the summer semester by UT meaning any credits he accumulated will be voided.

UT coach Phillip Fulmer suspended McDaniel for the first two games and said the second-team defensive tackle will also be forced to complete community service, attend anger management counseling and abide by a curfew for the fall semester.

Doctors inserted a metal plate to repair Goodrich’s cheekbone, one of four bones fractured on the right side of his face. Two eye socket bones and a sinus cavity were also broken.

Goodrich said that doctors told him that if the punch had landed four inches higher, closer to his temple, he could have suffered brain damage, been blinded, or even killed.

The video was made available to the News Sentinel by the Tennessee Public Records Law.
 
#4
#4
BEFORE:
0731goodrich_e.jpg


AFTER:
0731blackeye_e.jpg
 
#7
#7
19:29:46 when he drops.......

19:30:50 when three guys finally stop and look him over

19:31:12 when someone kneels beside him

19:36:00 Video ends, still no police or EMT's.

Bad enough to seek a civil suit, but no one there thought it was bad enough to call the police or EMT's quickly? I've worked on a campus before, the response time would have much sooner, had someone cared enough to call when it happened.
 
#9
#9
1 Punch... 2 Games of your junior season......community service....corrective conseling...and a curfew all Fall.....yes. I do.

Question is, what is the KNS's agenda by shwoing this video now?
 
#11
#11
Originally posted by BeltwayVol@Aug 3, 2005 9:46 PM
1 Punch...  2 Games of your junior season......community service....corrective conseling...and a curfew all Fall.....yes.  I do.

Question is, what is the KNS's agenda by shwoing this video now?
[snapback]121316[/snapback]​



prob going to be a civil suit huh? they are just fueling the fire.
 
#12
#12
It looks to me like the victim isn't really unconscious in that video. I saw him raise his arm at least once.
 
#13
#13
Originally posted by GOT TWELVE?@Aug 3, 2005 9:41 PM
do you guys feel that his punishment is fair???
[snapback]121310[/snapback]​



I think one punch in a fight is not "felony" material. As for the # of games, it depends on if there are mitigating or other circumstances - if he has a history, then he should get more. If no history, then 2 + the counseling, community service, etc. seems appropriate.


How about you GOT TWELVE?
 
#14
#14
Yes, it was fair. But remember he is on a very short leash, any screw ups and he'll be gone.

That video only tells part of the story.
 
#15
#15
I had not seen this tape.

From what the media had said, I thought there was a real confrontation and a real fight.

This had to be the shortest fight in the history of fights.

I didn't even see the punch thrown.
 
#16
#16
Originally posted by OldVol@Aug 4, 2005 12:02 AM
I had not seen this tape.

From what the media had said, I thought there was a real confrontation and a real fight.

This had to be the shortest fight in the history of fights.

I didn't even see the punch thrown.
[snapback]121391[/snapback]​



Not true. Ever seen the Mike Tyson vs. Mike Spinks fight?


Sorry. Probably in poor taste.
 
#17
#17
Originally posted by Atreus21@Aug 4, 2005 1:27 AM
Not true.  Ever seen the Mike Tyson vs. Mike Spinks fight?
Sorry.  Probably in poor taste.
[snapback]121395[/snapback]​


actually the Tyson fight lasted longer
 
#18
#18
I had to watch this about 10 times just to make heads and tails of it.

It looks like McD got fouled? Now im not sure, exactly what it takes to roll a 6'7" 295 DT to the ground.
I do not want to know...Im not saying it was right, but what ever the guy did to dump McD to the ground must have had intent?

He reacted before he thought! He punched'and knocked the guy, tha @$#% out!


Again not saying its right! But i believe the punishment fits the crime, Not only does McD have all the above due's. He also has to pay the Dr bills.

If you have ever had to have bones pieced backed together, You'll know it isnt cheap!

McD will not knock anyone else out until LSU sept 24th, And Mr.Goodrich wont be body blocking any more DTs in basketball for the rest of his life.
 
#19
#19
Originally posted by IBleedOrange24/7@Aug 3, 2005 11:27 PM
It looks like McD got fouled? Now im not sure, exactly what it takes to roll a 6'7" 295 DT to the ground.
[snapback]121403[/snapback]​

Guys that are that tall have a high center of gravity and fall easily. I have had a couple of friends that are in the 6'4" to 6'6" 220lb.+ range and are suprisingly easy to knock over.
 
#20
#20
This can be ended real quick. The only persons thoughts on this matter that counts has said his peace and that is the way it's going to be. Fulmer
 
#21
#21
Very much agree!

Glad its all over for now....

Just my take on what i viewed, milo i agree as well.

At a big 5'7" 155lbs myself, wonder if there wasnt some kind of intent etc, That sparked this....? Why take the legs of a lettered DT out in a friendly B-Ball game?

I guess being "cute" on the court, He might have gained somewhere? If McD had not responded with a broke face?

We'd never heard of this if McD was out for the season recouping from a knee, leg, muscle/tendon tear etc...Would Mr Goodrich been sued for taking out a Volunteer DT?

The kids need to stay out of situations, when they can become easy money! This is for CPF to address..
 
#22
#22
Originally posted by BeltwayVol@Aug 3, 2005 9:46 PM
Question is, what is the KNS's agenda by shwoing this video now?
[snapback]121316[/snapback]​


I'm just guessing, but Iwould imagine that this video was part of the trial evidence and therefore could not be shown until after the case had its day in court. No agenda necessarily, just the first time it was available.
 

VN Store



Back
Top