I have been thinking about Mike Hamilton lately. I don't think he has made as many major mistakes as we think. He has made some gaffes as well as coaching hires/fires pluses/minuses
(1) Football
* Getting rid of Fulmer was not a mistake. Tennessee fans were voting with their feet as attendance was plummeting as the quality of play was dropping.
* Hiring Lane Kiffin was a big/avoidable mistake. I hated it from the beginning.
* Allowing Kiffin to hire Orgeron with all the NCAA warnings? Inexcusable.
* Even though Kiffin & Co. broke rules, it appears that MH did everything he could to CYA the university at department.
* I'm not upset with the Dooley hire, being that late in the recruiting season and well after all other positions have been filed, I think Dooley was about as good as could be expected. Kiffin's late departure made the Dooley hire a necessity.
(2) Basketball
*MH did the right thing in getting rid of Buzz
*MH did the right thing in hiring Bruce
*MH did the wrong thing in not CYA the university and department last August.
*MH was forced to get rid of Bruce by the NCAA and Jimmy Cheek
*MH's Hyamms interview prior to NCAA was completely insane. There was no sense doing what he did!
(3) Baseball
*MH did the right/necessary thing in getting rid of Rod. Performance, APR, dropping attendance, drama, etc.
*MH did the wrong thing in getting rid of Rod before the stadium plans were finalyzed. Sometimes you have to "build it before they come". A higher profile coaches would express more interest in UT with stadium and training stuff being constructed.
*MH did the worst thing ever by hiring Todd Raleigh. There was no excuse. If he wanted a mid or low major coach, there were far better qualified people than this joker.
*MH did the wrong thing in giving Todd this 4th season. It was obvious that this team was going to be no better than last season.
*Finally, the slow pace of stadium construction WAS retarded! Better planning was necessary to get the new grandstands and batting cages constructed in a more timely manner.
(4)Other sports
*Simply put, why does John Trembley (Swimming) still have a job at UT. This team stinks to the point that Trembley is not getting SEC COY of the Year honors for moral victory 3rd place finishes. With Trembley's obvious extracurricular distractions including out-of-state programs as well as a questionable known substance abuse history why does MH keep this second tier coach as we now have a new facility?
*Track & Field- MH took a chance on making the women's coach the head of both programs. Thus far it has been unsuccessful as the Vols program is in a slump whose duration has not been seen in decades. It may still work out but right now it does not look good.
*Golf- our golf team still sucks. The planning and mistakes in construction of the golf facility (entering its 3rd big year) is an ugly soar everyone who drives on Alcoa Hwy sees everyday.
*Tennis- likely MH's biggest success, he hired the right guy for the job (not the most popular) and it's worked in spades. Proof that hiring the inexperienced alumnus (like Woodruff) is not the best thing to do.
Yes, I think Mike has made more than enough mistakes to justify a change in course. I would kill for an AD like Jeremy Foley who expects and strives for excellence in all programs and will make needed changes immediately rather than wait for a program to slowly die.
However, I don't hold all the problems at MH's feet, just most.