Comparing QBs......

[Fine Vol]

I hear this alot "Eli Manning will be as good or better than Peyton. I say no, what do you think? Also is Grossman the real deal or just streaky?

 

[TennTradition]

I hear this alot "Eli Manning will be as good or better than Peyton. I say no, what do you think? Also is Grossman the real deal or just streaky?

Eli may win the big one before Peyton....but as far as basics go..I think Peyton will continue to be the better QB. Grossmann is not the real deal.

 

[Volunteer_Kirby]

What does this have to do with the Vols again? :ermm:

 

[Hoosier_Vol]

I see this going to the NFL Section real quick..lol...I think Eli may win a SB before Peyton but ONLY because he has a very good defense to go with a above average offense. There is no doubt Peyton is the better and smarter QB between the two. I honestly think Peyton is the best QB the NFL has ever seen. If the Colts had the Giants "D" they would have won the SB last year and this year along with going undefeated both seasons. I think this years Colts team is more focused than last years despit several recent close games.

As far as Grossman goes, I think he's overrated. The way to beat the Bears is get 10 pts up on them and pressure Rex. He hasn't shown he can make the big throws when his team is behind by two scores. He's also one of the most fumble prone QB's in the league. I don't see the comparisons to Farve they keep trying to make. JMO