A friend of mines brother played on the 98 national championship team. This guy was a starting D lineman. He told me Cutcliffe was responsible for recruiting him as well as many of the players on that team. Basically Cutcliffe was the coach the players liked and the reason for a lot of their success! He said Cutcliffe was twice the coach Fulmer was.
I think Cutcliffe is a great QB coach and obviously he's a great x and o guy on offense. Prior to coming to coach at UT, he was a high school coach. By the time he worked himself to TE coach, Walt Harris was the OC.
In his six years, Harris helped the Vols to two nine win seasons and one ten win season. After a disappointing 5-6 season, Harris moved on and Fulmer became the OC for the "89 season. (Incidentally, Randy Sanders was the QB in 1988.)
29-6-2. That's Johnny Major's best 3 seasons and Fulmer was the OC for those three, '89-'91.
1992 was the year Majors was hospitalized, Fulmer went 4-0 in his absence, the rest is history.
In '93 Cutcliffe becomes Fulmer's OC. Cut's already been on the staff for 10 years!
From '93 to '98, the Vols went 63-11! Of course, '98 was the year that the "National Champions are clad in ORANGE!"
Cut would leave, in '99, for Ole Miss and the torch was passed to Sanders.
Offensively, a lot of principles were passed down. Obviously, when you're talking about Majors, Fulmer, Sanders, Chavis and the like, you're talking about quite a bit of football philosophy being passed down from the General himself.
The terminology of the offense was passed down too and that kind of stability is an advantage. This is not to say that Cut didn't bring anything new to the table, offense is always evolving...but he could keep it within the frame work of what everyone already knew because he'd been with the program for so long.
Obviously, if Archie Manning wants you to coach his sons, he has a lot of faith in you. Look where Manning went to throw after his neck surgery.
The truth is, Fulmer and Cut and Chavis were good together. They are obviously fine football coaches and gave their all, VFL etc...