Cheaters don't get wins. Therefore Bama lost in '93. Also, Spurrier does not get credit for an SEC Championship in '90... again cheaters should not get rewarded.
W/O Wuerrfel, Spurrier won only 2 SEC Titles, 1 SEC Championship Game win, 0 National Titles, and 0 National Title Game appearances. His record at Florida w/o Wuerrfel is 77-21 (78.57%).
Spurrier won't be considered among the great coaches of all-time unless he wins multiple national championships.
Fulmer w/o Manning is 94-29 (76.42%). His all-time record is now at 134-38 (77.91%). His regular season record is 125-30 (80.65%). Fulmer has an all-time record versus ranked opponents of 39-28 (58.21%) and w/o Manning is 29-21 (58.00%). All-time, he is 16-20 (44.44%) versus the top 10. W/O Manning, he is 14-15 versus the top 10 (48.28%). His all-time SEC record is 84-25 (77.06%) and w/o Manning it is 58-19 (75.32%).
Ooh, those are some good stats my man. Thanks for posting them. The last vs top 10 stats I saw were different, but I trust yours.
1. If you take out Wuerffel, that means Spurrier only coached them for 8 seasons. Within those 8, he won 4 SEC titles, one of which you stripped (which is fair, because they did cheat). If yout take it out, he won 3 in 7 seasons. Thus, in 11 seaons w/out the '90 year, he won 6 SEC titles. It doesn't get much better than that, IMO. Comparatively, CPF has won 2 SEC titles in 14 seasons.
2. Keep in mind also that FL played FSU every year when FSU was unbeatable. That one game makes a big difference over time. I would argue that FSU had slightly better talent, on average, then FL did during the 90's.
3. He has the all-time best SEC win%, which I think is pretty good.
4. NC's aren't a good baromter, because we don't have a playoff. I almost don't even consider what we have as a NC system. They are icing type games to me. Playing in the SEC keeps a lot of great teams from at least getting a shot. TN in '95 would have had a shot, but was relegated to the Citrus Bowl.
5. With comparable talent, Spurrier owned CPF when CPF had his best teams. They beat us up from 91-97, save '92.
Like I said, I think CPF's record is very good. It's just not great. And I don't think it is all that comaparable to Visor's. Moreover, generalization stats need to be placed in context, else they be mined.