Living amongst the Bammers, I've unfortunately gained some insight into their thinking (I use that word lightly).
The hiring of Saban convinced Tiders that they would soon return to their rightful place.
Reality has not been matched with expectations and thus has to be rationalized.
Conclusion? Nothing wrong with Saban - it is the players that are the problem. They are quitters, undisciplined, no heart, etc. (Last year, the players were fine but Shula was the problem)
Next year, the Tide will win 9 or 10 games and all will be right until Year 3 when they win 7 games and you will suddenly hear:
Saban doesn't do (fill in blank) like the Bear.
Seeing the writing on the wall, Saban will bolt.