wow, that is a tough question. Do they get to use their respective sidearms? Because that could be the difference. If they can, I would go with Indiana. That whip would increase his range by about 10 feet. I suppose I would also take IJ in a fight without weapons. As badass as HS is, you never really see if him in hand to hand combat too much, so I don't really know how he would fare. Plus he's always got Chewie, Luke etc. to help him out. IJ on the other hand is usually dispensing out lots of pain all by himself. So I'm going with Indiana Jones.