Kiffin is an f'n dick and that's messed up.
With that said, he could have refused. I know Kiffin was (allegedly)threatening to pull his scholarship, but sometimes in life you have to grow up, make your own decisions, and weigh your options. Do I want to be healthy and find another way to finish school or do I want to keep my scholarship at the risk of brain damage? He chose brain damage. It's really sad and I feel bad for him but he had a choice. Hopefully the injury isn't permanent because what good is that scholarship you played for if you have mental problems. Then again, it also says "Baucham was a backup defensive back at USC in 2009 and 2010, but was ruled academically ineligible for the 2011 season". So, sounds like his scholarship was going to waste anyways, at least in 2011.
I'm not trying to sound unsympathetic, but define "forced". If someone says they will give you ice cream but you don't want to do what they're asking and eventually you give in and do what they're asking so you can get the ice cream... you weren't forced to do anything. You just wanted the ice cream and were willing to do what it took to get it. Obviously a scholarship is worth a lot more than ice cream, but you get the idea. In reality, he wasn't forced to do anything. He was given an ultimatum and he made the decision. Again, Kiffin is a giant p.o.s. for doing what he did but "forced" is excessive. "Forced" would be if Kiffin drug his ass up and down the field. Obviously, Kiffin isn't capable of that. My opinion probably sounds really crappy but it's also kind of crappy if you can sue someone because you made a decision to trade your health for a scholarship(even though you weren't passing). And yes, it's even more crappy that Kiffin would yank his scholarship for not going back out. So, in no way am I defending Kiffin. I think that's one of the scummiest things I've ever heard a college coach do. I'm just not going to refer to it as being "forced". Forced is when you do something against your will with no decision in the matter. He had a decision though. jmo, albeit sounding horrible.