So since your theory is that players randomly, intentionally withhold effort, how do you gain control of this willful misbehavior? I'd think you'd have to understand why they'd make such a bizarre choice to look bad on national TV, lose games, lose respect, and lose possible future earnings. I know I personally can't understand it every time I hear this oversimplified 'effort" bull crap. But then I'm not a coach.
Of course they don't intentionally withhold effort in some kind of silly mind game power struggle with coaches. Is that how you coach? Effort often gets confused with focus, which can come in spurts(so to speak). Sometimes, too many times in our case, players are not properly focused and mentally zoned in to play. That is the hardest thing, IMO, for players to achieve and coaches to coach. Learning to consistently be mentally "present", stick to game plan, stay locked in is what makes great teams great. It's a process like every other aspect of developing as a player. Lack of it is not caused by players randomly deciding to suck out loud. Never going to get fixed by a coach who doesn't understand that.
All that said, it is true that sometimes frustration caused by sucking in public leds some players to dog it toward the end of bad games. That is definitely willful misbehavior and should be addressed, like any ingame improper displays.
Once again, my bothersome little friend, you have misstated my thoughts.
"players randomly, intentionally withhold effort",,,That is a laughable interpretation of my ideology
All players
WANT to perform, but some have to be guided more than others and they have to be guided by the right type of persona. You can not ASK for an alpha athlete's focus and effort, you have to demand it and know how to get it out of them when they don't know how to get it out of them-self. . . They give their respect and acceptance,, to who they respect, not to who asks for it!
Beta players want to please. Alpha players want to perform. And each of the types have to be influenced differently. A coach has to understand their players, just as a boss has to understand their employees...Some you pat on the back and brag on and they get hyped-up and want to give you even more,,,,,and some you put your foot into their backside and demand they give you more and out of respect they give you more....and then there are the one's in the middle, the Alpha-Beta's who can swing either way and sometimes they are the trickiest to read.
I almost NEVER struggle to get full effort out of my players bc I understand this phenomenon. I KNOW that I can get the best out of my Alpha's and I can also get the best out of my Beta's....BUT, when I can't read a Beta player, I also know that sometimes I have to give that player to one of my assistant coaches and let them be what I am not. . . I struggle immensely with players that have to be "coddled" yet, these players can often be as dominant as the aggressive Alpha's, and thus are equally able and equal in the sport,,,So, I KNOW I have to have the right person in my org to handle those players for me.
++++++
glv, there is nothing I can say to you that will ever let you understand me, or my way, bc, you have it in your mind to try to confront me in every way you can...If I coached you, quite simply, I'd trade you or force you into quitting...A great man once said, "A man's got to know his limitations" (Clint Eastwood) , . . And you are mine!