I watched this all-star game four years ago, I thiink, and it became another lesson in the perils of following recruiting too closely. BOTH starting forwards on one of the teams were Vol soccer signees--Alicia Donley and Colleen McIlvenna, both out of Ohio, probably four-star recruits, both tall and athletic. Not only did they both start, but they scored three goals between them for the winning team in the game. I thought, wow, we've got two good ones here. Well, Donley played a fair amount at forward a freshman, looked promising, and I think had the 3rd or 4th most shots on the team, and even scored a couple of goals, as I recall. McIlvenna didn't play much at all, which I found a bit curious for someone who has both size and speed.
As sophs, Donley again got a decent amount of minutes as a substitute forward, again had a number of shots--and had, as I recall, the 2nd highest SOG percentage on the team--meaning that she got her shots on net as opposed to hitting the ball 10 feet over the crossbar. However, about halfway through the season, Pensky moved Donley to more of a wing/midfield position--and it was easy to see that the move did not suit Donley: she seemed lost in the midfield and, to me, seemed a bit too tall for a midfield position requiring a lot of quick-twitch agility. As a result of playing farther back on the pitch, her shot production fell off. Meanwhile, McIlvenna again spent most of her time on the bench.
The following season, both were gone, having decided to transfer. Donley now plays for the University of Dayton. She played in almost every game, started 7/8 games and scored 5 goals for a good Dayton team, which came in 2nd in the Atlantic 10 conference and I think came close to making the NCAA tourney. McIlvenna transferred to Holy Cross, which seems an unfortunate decision as Holly Cross was terrible last year. The Crusaders did not win a game. McIlvenna started nearly every game and was the team's second leading point scorer, which isn't saying a lot: She had 2 goals and 3 assists. She surely dropped down in class too much by going to Holy Cross and, if she is really serious about her soccer career, might consider transferring again, as she could start for a lot of teams better than Holy Cross. But these two players are examples of how unpredictable--and, in a lot of cases, disappointing, college careers can be after players who seem to have good promise sign their scholarship papers and actually get on the field. The level of play is higher, there is competition for starting spots, you might be asked by the coach to play a position that you've never played before, etc. Let's hope things work out better for our two participants in this year's game! My sense is that Reisz is going to be a very good keeper. Fingers crossed!