McNeill 5 star ?

[508mikey]

Looks like a mistake like Palardys rating was -- I hope they didnt sign him because of the stars rating - he is not even close to a SEC type DB

 

[The Orange Pants]

Fail.

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

He's a Freshman bro. Give the kid a break, he's in a tough spot.

 

[Darkvol]

Smh

 

[ric1958]

He's a Freshman bro. Give the kid a break, he's in a tough spot.

I agree with you. I think now I`m gonna throw up.

 

[VolWonder]

Have to think he was a product of failed coaching..tools had to be there to get the rating.

Like a mechanic (coach). You could have all the tools in the shop to use to fix a car but if you don't even know what an engine looks like the tool is just a shiny piece of metal

 

[volfanCLT]

McNeil is SEC caliber. His coaching and schemes this year were not. The kids have to be put in a position to succeed.

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

I agree with you. I think now I`m gonna throw up.

Uh, ok then.

 

[508mikey]

5 stars are supposed to be good enough to start as freshman - see UF, Alabama , and LSU - no reason he couldnt stop that Kentucky RB

 

[vol2002]

Like Gray in the Troy game, he has been thrown into the fire too early. We shouldn't have to rely on freshmen to win.

 

[volfanCLT]

5 stars are supposed to be good enough to start as freshman - see UF, Alabama , and LSU - no reason he couldnt stop that Kentucky RB

Was he a 5*? I thought I remembered him being a 4*? I could be wrong

 

[volfrk86]

I think he is one of our top Dbs our safteys have not been the problem. They are having to make too many plays in space because our front seven sucks other than AJ Johnson.

 

[508mikey]

He's a Freshman bro. Give the kid a break, he's in a tough spot.

So was Teague - quit making excuses for bad plays

 

[TNsnyper20]

5 stars are supposed to be good enough to start as freshman - see UF, Alabama , and LSU - no reason he couldnt stop that Kentucky RB

He's played really well this year... So give it up.

 

[AV_12]

Miss. Mcneil that is.

 

[ric1958]

Uh, ok then.

Oooops, sorry not who I thought you were. :hi:

 

[508mikey]

Was he a 5*? I thought I remembered him being a 4*? I could be wrong

depends on the scouting service - Palardy was a 3 star but still number 1 ranked

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

So was Teague - quit making excuses for bad plays

There is so much bad on this defense man, its hard to pick and choose. LM has an excuse, he's a freshman.

 

[volfanCLT]

depends on the scouting service - Palardy was a 3 star but still number 1 ranked

Now that is one bust we can agree on lol

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

Oooops, sorry not who I thought you were. :hi:

Cheers:hi:

 

[LLcoolDave]

I think he was a 4* by most services. don't recall a 5* rating attached to McNeil but may be wrong. anyway, not sure what the op is looking at. McNeil, if he continues to learn and keep his head on straight, will become an all-sec type player, imo, tifwiw, wtf.

 

[Jax_Vol]

He was not a five star...gheez people...he was playing high school ball this time last year

 

[volfrk86]

Mcneil will start next year along side Brian Randolph no question.

 

[DEFENDTHISHOUSE]

One thing we can all agree on, they need a much better DB coach.

 

[jguy2]

depends on the scouting service - Palardy was a 3 star but still number 1 ranked

That's as high as kicker rankings go, and mcneil wasn't a 5* on any recruiting service. We haven't had a 5* since Da'Rick.