More BCS Controversy?

#1

allvol

Eternally Optimistic
Joined
Aug 10, 2004
Messages
3,778
Likes
977
#1
This just in from collegebcs.com ........

"The BCS honchos are probably breathing a big sigh of relief over the fact that the first release of the ratings is next week and not this week. I say "probably," because they may not even know how embarrassing it would have been for them. Both Colley and Anderson-Hester published erroneous ratings this week. Colley might have had his corrected in time for BCS publication. I alerted him to his error before the typical Monday afternoon BCS release time. However, Anderson-Hester wasn't published until sometime on Tuesday, the day after the typical BCS release time. They have been notified as well, but those ratings remain inaccurate as of Tuesday evening, which is why they are not updated on my BCS ratings page.

I am not writing this to pick on these guys or suggest that they do not know what they're doing. Misteaks are rare, and none of us humans are immune. However, I am concerned that nobody at BCS HQ seems to be validating these numbers. I say that because I was told that the BCS computation and publication machine went through a dry run this weekend, and these errors weren't caught until I saw them. If I were the BCS people, I would not want to depend on me or anyone else outside their structure to spot these errors. I'd want to make sure they were right before I went to press."
 
#2
#2
FYI, Jerry Palm at collegebcs.com is the same guy who pointed out an error to the BCS folks back in 1998...

"The BCS had a great deal of difficulty implementing its SOS formula throughout this first season. During the 1998 season, I was never able to exactly match the SOS [stength-of-schedule] rankings with the official release, although I could come close. I believe that was because either the data the BCS using was bad or the formula was being applied incorrectly. After the bowls, Jeff Sagarin released a document called the "CORRECT 1998 Bowl Championship Series Schedule Strength." Sagarin does the SOS calculation for the BCS ratings, although the formula is not his. The emphasis on "CORRECT" is his. I had no trouble whatsoever matching the numbers on the "CORRECT" document, and this is why I believe the problems I had (and still have) matching the numbers for the 1998 season were due to errors in the official release."

Makes you wonder who is running the henhouse :yikes:

Good thing Palm is watching, because the so-called "computer rankings" could really just put out whatever they wanted and the BCS folks would not know. :blink:
 
#3
#3
doesnt suprise me...these days almost everyone does a half azzed job at everything. Whether it be the guy in town that does your brake job or the guy that tabulates bcs ratings.
 

VN Store



Back
Top