National Championship Quarterbacks

#1
tvolsfan

tvolsfan

VN GURU
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
39,723
Likes
12,839
#1
Rank the BCS title winning quarterbacks based on who you would want most on your team.

Rank them based on their performance at the collegiate level, and leave out off the field stuff.
 
#2
#2
1. Tim Tebow
2. Vince Young
3. Cam Newton
4. Matt Leinart
5. Chris Weinke
6. Josh Heupel
7. Tee Martin
8. Ken Dorsey
9. Chris Leak
10. Matt Mauck
11. Greg McElroy
12. Craig Krenzel
13. Matt Flynn
 
Last edited:
#3
#3
1. Young
2. Tebow
3. Newton (would be higher, but I only got to see him for one season)
4. Leinart
5. Weinke (I don't remember him too well, so a lot of this is just based on stats)
6. Heupel (I don't remember him too well, either, so again, a lot based on stats)
7. Mauk
8. Leak
9. Martin (Unfortunately, I can't remember him too well, either, so forgive me if you think he should be higher)
10. McElroy
11. Dorsey (I'm kind of torn on him. He had the great record and everything, but I feel like any of the guys above could have done as well with that team)
12. Flynn
13. Krenzel
 
#4
#4
1. Vince Young
2. Tim Tebow
3. Cam Newton
4. Matt Leinhart
5. Josh Heupel
6. Ken Dorsey
7. Chris Weinke
8. Tee Martin
9. Matt Mauck
10. Greg McElroy
11. Chris Leak
12. Matt Flynn
13. Craig Krenzel
 
#9
#9
tvolsfan said:
1. Young
2. Tebow
3. Newton (would be higher, but I only got to see him for one season)
4. Leinart
5. Weinke (I don't remember him too well, so a lot of this is just based on stats)
6. Heupel (I don't remember him too well, either, so again, a lot based on stats)
7. Mauk
8. Leak
9. Martin (Unfortunately, I can't remember him too well, either, so forgive me if you think he should be higher)
10. McElroy
11. Dorsey (I'm kind of torn on him. He had the great record and everything, but I feel like any of the guys above could have done as well with that team)
12. Flynn
13. Krenzel
Click to expand...

I would take Martin over Leak.

Weinke was good but he's kind of like Leinart to me, he had such a great supporting cast he just didn't have to turn the ball over.
 
#11
#11
tvolsfan said:
1. Young
2. Tebow
3. Newton (would be higher, but I only got to see him for one season)
4. Leinart
5. Weinke (I don't remember him too well, so a lot of this is just based on stats)
6. Heupel (I don't remember him too well, either, so again, a lot based on stats)
7. Mauk
8. Leak
9. Martin (Unfortunately, I can't remember him too well, either, so forgive me if you think he should be higher)
10. McElroy
11. Dorsey (I'm kind of torn on him. He had the great record and everything, but I feel like any of the guys above could have done as well with that team)
12. Flynn
13. Krenzel
Click to expand...

Would take him over Mauk and Leak.
 
#13
#13
1. I hate it but, Tebow
2. Young
3. Leinart
4. Newton
5. A little homerism, Martin
6. Dorsey
7. Wienke
8. McElroy
9. Mauck
10. Leak
11. Heupel
12. Flynn
13. Krenzel
 
#15
#15
Wasn't Ken Dorsey very interested in UT during the same time UT was recruiting Chris Simms, or am I remembering that wrong?
Posted via VolNation Mobile
 
Last edited:
#16
#16
DarthVisor said:
Wasn't Ken Dorsey very interested in IT during the same time UT was recruiting Chris Simms, or am I remembering that wrong?
Posted via VolNation Mobile
Click to expand...
His major or future career path was really irrelevant. Why?
Posted via VolNation Mobile
 
#20
#20
Tebow
Cam
VY


like somebody else said tebow got way better leadership skills VY has proven to be a frickin headcase
 
#22
#22
DarthVisor said:
Wasn't Ken Dorsey very interested in UT during the same time UT was recruiting Chris Simms, or am I remembering that wrong?
Posted via VolNation Mobile
Click to expand...

yes he was, but during the whole process Simms (who was the class's top QB) became a "solid" verbal commit (like before January) so the school stopped pursuing Dorsey

...makes sense considering the situation/time; in retrospect with what Simms ended up pulling, looks a bit different
 
#23
#23
BIG BOI 23 said:
Tebow
Cam
VY


like somebody else said tebow got way better leadership skills VY has proven to be a frickin headcase
Click to expand...

I think the point of this is just their college season / the bowl games, not anything that's happened before that or since then

if the latter were the idea, then guys like Martin & Leak would have to drop to the bottom....
 
Last edited:
#24
#24
Vince young was a monster in college. The game against USC was the best performance I've seen by a player in the bcs championship game.
Posted via VolNation Mobile
 
#25
#25
865dude said:
Vince young was a monster in college. The game against USC was the best performance I've seen by a player in the bcs championship game.
Posted via VolNation Mobile
Click to expand...

Agreed, but I wouldn't trade Tebow and his 4 years at UF for anyone.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top