VOLinthaNATI
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 5, 2006
- Messages
- 15,501
- Likes
- 2
When the best hitter on a team goes down, the entire lineup suffers.
Cruz can still hit a baseball just the same but he isn't going to get the same pitches without Hamilton in the lineup.
Baseball 101.
The lineup production suffers because David Murphy is not Josh Hamilton, not because the rest of the lineup, i.e. Nelson Cruz, will do far worse.
It might matter SOME in very weak lineups, but this team doesn't fit that bill.
The reigning MVP provides MVP numbers and absolutely mashes the baseball. That is where the lineup/production suffers. Josh Hamilton > David Murphy. It doesn't make Cruz, or whoever, a better or worse hitter.
If Hamilton was protecting Cruz in the lineup, ie, batting right after him or something like that, it might make a difference. In all the box scores I've looked up, Hamilton was batting 2-3 spots ahead of Cruz and so is Murphy. That's baseball 101. Cruz's # will differentiate just because no one can go on such a tear for so long, but the theory of it being the loss of Josh Hamilton is wrong. If anything came from losing Josh Hamilton, it would be pitchers going right at Nelson Cruz because there is no one on base. I doubt that happens though.
If Hamilton was protecting Cruz in the lineup, ie, batting right after him or something like that, it might make a difference. In all the box scores I've looked up, Hamilton was batting 2-3 spots ahead of Cruz and so is Murphy. That's baseball 101. Cruz's # will differentiate just because no one can go on such a tear for so long, but the theory of it being the loss of Josh Hamilton is wrong. If anything came from losing Josh Hamilton, it would be pitchers going right at Nelson Cruz because there is no one on base. I doubt that happens though.