Oil Can Boyd -vs- Fernando Valenzuela

Billy Costigan · Jul 23, 2011

Oil Can

Fernando

In your honest opinion, which guy would you say was the better pitcher?

JTrainDavis · Jul 23, 2011

Fernando. But its a lot closer than you'd think.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

Billy Costigan · Jul 23, 2011

JTrainDavis said:
Fernando. But its a lot closer than you'd think.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

I agree it's very close but I would have to give Oil Can the edge.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

SDV · Jul 23, 2011

Fernando by a mile

whocaresgobobcats · Jul 23, 2011

Never saw either play, but statistically it's Valenzuela. Oil Can had a nice run from 84-86 though.

govols120 · Jul 23, 2011

Valenzuela. Better and longer career and a better and longer peak.