Poll: Best or most impressive single-game performance by Tennessee as a team ever?

Best or most impressive single-game performance by Tennessee as a team ever?


  • Total voters
    0
#1

Volosaurus rex

Doctorate in Volology
Joined
Dec 2, 2009
Messages
6,008
Likes
4,204
#1
What do you consider to be the best or most impressive single-game performance by Tennessee as a team in the history of the program? Ideally, the “correct” answer would be a game in which Tennessee played well, in all phases of the game, from start to finish against a highly ranked opponent in a meaningful context (rivalry, championship or bowl game) and dominated that opponent, as opposed to mounting a furious comeback. Unfortunately, few, if any, games meet all of these criteria. I consider the following, however, to be representative of our finest performances, certainly within the last 50 years, but there are many other worthy candidates. Indeed, one could select a host of legitimate contenders just from Tennessee’s biggest victories over Alabama (1928, 1969, 1970, 1982, and 1995) and Florida (1970, 1990, 1998, and 2001), so feel free to add “write in” votes as needed.

Nominees from the modern era include the following:

(1) 1986 Sugar Bowl. In a classic confrontation of David vs. Goliath, eighth-ranked Tennessee defeated 2nd-ranked Miami, 35-7. In one of the greatest and most inspired defensive performances in Big Orange history, Tennessee held Miami’s vaunted offense to 269 offensive yards, sacked Vinnie Testaverde seven times for 84 yard, forced six turnovers and an astounding twenty-four plays for negative yardage. At the time, they were ranked No. 2 and scheduled to play No. 8-ranked Tennessee in the Sugar Bowl. Johnson said if Miami won and the No. 1 team lost, his team should be voted national champions.

(2) 1990 Florida game. Spurrier’s first Florida team, which was undefeated (5-0) and ranked 10th nationally, trailed only 7-3 at halftime. Dale Carter’s 91-yd. touchdown return on the 2nd half-kickoff opened the floodgates and the 9th-ranked Volunteers rode a tidal wave of six 2nd.-half turnovers to bury the Reptilian Horde by the final margin of 45-3.

(3) 2001: No. 4 Tennessee 34 - No. 2 Florida 32 (Gainesville). In, perhaps, the most exciting and highly competitive game in the history of this series, Tennessee, which was an 18.5-point underdog, defeated Flotida 34-32 in Spurrier’s last game at the Swamp. Travis Stephens turned in a performance for the ages, running for 226 yards and two touchdowns on 19 carries.

(4) 1969 Alabama game. I am sure that younger Tennessee fans will probably favor streak-breaking victories over the Tide in 1995 or 1982, but Tennessee amassed a 34-0 lead in this game before pulling its starters and coasting to a 41-14 victory. SEC Defensive Player of the Year and a consensus All-American, Steve Kiner was a one-man wrecking crew at linebacker, amassing “five sacks, 11 tackles with five assists, four quarterback hurries, an interception and a forced fumble” (University of Tennessee Athletics Football). As he came off the field, Kiner scolded the Tidy Bowl boys by saying, “Look at that old man (Bryant). He looks pitiful. There was a time when those crimson jerseys meant something.”

(5) 2002 Citrus Bowl. In our only game against Michigan thus far, the Volunteers handed the Wolverines what was then their worst bowl loss of all-time, 45-17. Witten’s long touchdown served as an absolutely perfect exclamation point for the day’s festivities. No tight end is supposed to outrun a top-tier secondary. Although the 2001 team lost the SEC Championship game to LSU, very few teams in the history of college football can lay claim to beating Alabama (35-24), Notre Dame (28-18), Florida (34-32) and Michigan (45-17) in the same year.

(6) 1971 Penn State game. In their first matchup with Penn State, Tennessee stuns the powerful, 5th-ranked Nittany Lions 31-11. All-American Bobby Majors had a “a banner day on ‘Majors Family Day’ at Neyland Stadium against Penn State in his home finale in 1971, with 82 yards in punt returns -- one for a score covering 44 yards -- and 113 yards on kickoff returns.”

(7) 1991: No. 13 Tennessee 35 - No. 5 Notre Dame 34 (South Bend). The “Miracle at South Bend,” of course, will never go down as one of our most dominating performances but, as Majors stated, it was the most impressive comeback in Tennessee history, particularly against an opponent of Notre Dame’s stature, and it was the biggest come-from-behind victory by an opponent at Notre Dame’s field. Notre Dame looked like an absolute juggernaut in the first half. We were staring a 34-7 half-time deficit squarely in the eye before Floyd Miley returned a blocked FG attempt 76 yards for a touchdown. In a fitting conclusion to a truly legendary game, Jeremy Lincoln blocked a would-be game-winning FG with his rear end to secure a 35-34 victory.

(8) 1985 Auburn game. In its long and storied history, Tennessee has defeated only two number 1-ranked teams, one of which was the 1985 Auburn team, then led by Heisman Trophy winner, Bo Jackson. Tony Robinson riddled Auburn’s secondary for 259 yards and four touchdowns as Tennessee sprinted to a 24-0 halftime lead. The ’85 Vols did not yet possess the killer instinct that they would later exhibit against Miami, however. They surrendered 20 cosmetic points but still walked away with a comfortable 38-20 victory.

(9) 2003 Miami game. In a game that was virtually a throwback to the era of leather helmets, defense and punting, the 13th-ranked Vols, who were two-touchdown underdogs, defeated 4th-ranked Miami 10-6 in the Orange Bowl, breaking the Hurricanes’ 28-game home winning streak, and they do so without yielding a touchdown. Were it possible, General Neyland would have risen from his grave and saluted the tremendous effort by Tennessee’s defense and special teams in this game.

(10) 1999 BCS National Championship Game. Tennessee-23, Florida State-16. It certainly wasn’t the prettiest win in Tennessee history. Indeed, it was a fairly sloppy defensive struggle, punctuated by big plays from Peerless Price, Tee Martin and Duane Goodrich. It was, however, the most important victory in the modern era since it secured the first BCS National Championship and allowed John Ward to ride off into the sunset with the proclamation, "the national champion is clad in Big Orange!"
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#2
#2
1950 20-14 over heavily favored Texas in Cotton Bowl

Huge win against one of Texas' finest squads. Tenessee won 20 in a row in 50-51, so a lot of great wins there but this was probably the best of those.
 
#3
#3
Without a doubt for me it's the Sugar Bowl victory over Miami. Absolutely nobody gave us a chance in that game for good reason. Miami was easily the best team in the country that year with future pro bowl players all over the field.
Posted via VolNation Mobile
 
#5
#5
1950 20-14 over heavily favored Texas in Cotton Bowl

Huge win against one of Texas' finest squads. Tenessee won 20 in a row in 50-51, so a lot of great wins there but this was probably the best of those.

Definitely would have been a poll selection option if I could have expanded it beyond 10. Under the current format, Tennessee would have unquestionably won the national title since Kentucky beat top-ranked Oklahoma in the Sugar Bowl and we beat 3rd-ranked Texas (2nd in the UPI).
 
#6
#6
The 86 Sugar Bowl got us going back to the top again, and it had been about a 15 year dry spell, sorta reminds me of now, but it wont take 15 years this time because the BUTCHER is in the house.
 
#7
#7
:)Remember the OHIO STATE game with all the first round talent the buckeyes had and we still beat them, old cooper cost them a couple of NC, WAY TO GO john.:eek:lol:
 
#8
#8
Sugar Bowl and Citrus Bowl wins (Mich., Ohio State, and Northwestern) were all solid performances for 4 quarters.
 
#9
#9
1985 Sugar bowl. All the experts expected TN to not only lose but to get killed, and TN dominated. Plus it was a huge game as Miami was playing for a national title if they had been able to win.
 
#10
#10
I picked 2001 Florida.

We were 18 point underdogs on the road in the Swamp during Spurrier's prime.

That was just an epic all-time win with what was at stake.

If we went on to beat LSU the next week that would be talked about as the best game in TN history.
 
#11
#11
:)Remember the OHIO STATE game with all the first round talent the buckeyes had and we still beat them, old cooper cost them a couple of NC, WAY TO GO john.:eek:lol:

Yes. That team had Eddie George and Terry Glenn, who were, respectively, the 1995 Heisman and Biletnikoff Trophy winners, as well as Orlando Pace, the 1996 Outland Trophy winner.
 
#12
#12
Before looking at the list I thought of the two Miami games. Wound up going with the Sugar Bowl Victory cause I was there. After looking at the list, I also briefly considered the ND game ( Mainly cause I detest them so). The best part of the 86 win was the arrogant a$$ attitude of the Cane fans in attendance though. Man, Dale Jones shut that cocky bunch up - they were tucking tails and crawling out of the dome.
 
#13
#13
I picked 2001 Florida.

We were 18 point underdogs on the road in the Swamp during Spurrier's prime.

That was just an epic all-time win with what was at stake.

If we went on to beat LSU the next week that would be talked about as the best game in TN history.

If I take off my unashamedly orange-tinted glasses and critique it objectively, I would rank it as the most exciting, most evenly played game in the history of the series and, arguably, one of the truly great regular season matchups of all-time. It raises an interesting rhetorical question, however, one for which I do not have a definitive answer: Has Tennessee ever been a more prohibitive underdog and won? I would think not. I would also love to know just how badly the Vegas bookies fared that week.
 
#16
#16
I voted for the 01 victory over hated Florida. Besides the 95 Bama game,that is the most memorable game to me. I was only 5 during the Sugar Vols victory,so I was unable to properly appreciate it. The Draining of the Swamp was a victory that made me danged proud to wear Big Orange and be a Tennessean. The Iceman and Travis Stephens were the definition of clutch. I was living in Decatur,Al at the time. If anyone else was,they may remember a young man clad in orange riding a bicycle with HUGE UT flags flying screaming Rocky Top and Go Vols all night after that victory. That was moi. I always represented my Vols while I lived in that dump. Thankfully,I'm back in my beloved Jimtown,Tennessee. Go Vols!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#17
#17
to select some from the "non-obvious" category

2007 georgia
1989 auburn
2004 georgia
 
#18
#18
WebbVol32, Casey was a true road warrior but the most rewarding aspect of the '01 Florida game, given our status as huge underdogs, was that we absolutely whipped them up front and mauled them with our running game.
 
Last edited:
#19
#19
Gotta go with the '01 game against Florida...one of the greatest moments I ever had as a kid was watching that game!
 
#21
#21
The 1970 Florida game would fall in the "honorable mention" category. In Dickey’s return to Tennessee as Florida’s coach, Bobby Scott passed for a then-school record 385 yards and the Big Orange gave the lizards a world-class butt-kicking, 38-7.
 
#22
#22
to select some from the "non-obvious" category

2007 georgia
1989 auburn
2004 georgia

I agree with respect to the 1989 Auburn game. Tennessee turned in one of its most impressive team rushing performances against a quality SEC opponent, running for some 350 yards, including a 79-yd. touchdown jaunt by Reggie Cobb in the rain. The 21-14 final margin of victory was not truly indicative of the degree to which Tennessee physically whipped Auburn in that game.

Given the strength of the '07 Georgia team, Tennessee's 35-14 victory was, indeed, impressive. The 2004 Georgia team was stronger than the 2006 edition but I have to rate the manner in which we defeated them in '06 more highly. Then undefeated and sporting the number one defense in the country, Georgia sprinted to a 24-7 lead with :55 left in the 2nd quarter. From that point on, we outscored GA 44-9 for the rest of the game. Georgia’s only second-half touchdown was via a 4th-qtr. kickoff return. The last six Tennessee drives, not counting the one that concluded the game, resulted in 291 yds. on 48 plays, five touchdowns and a FG.
 
#23
#23
I agree with respect to the 1989 Auburn game. Tennessee turned in one of its most impressive team rushing performances against a quality SEC opponent, running for some 350 yards, including a 79-yd. touchdown jaunt by Reggie Cobb in the rain. The 21-14 final margin of victory was not truly indicative of the degree to which Tennessee physically whipped Auburn in that game.

Given the strength of the '07 Georgia team, Tennessee's 35-14 victory was, indeed, impressive. The 2004 Georgia team was stronger than the 2006 edition but I have to rate the manner in which we defeated them in '06 more highly. Then undefeated and sporting the number one defense in the country, Georgia sprinted to a 24-7 lead with :55 left in the 2nd quarter. From that point on, we outscored GA 44-9 for the rest of the game. Georgia’s only second-half touchdown was via a 4th-qtr. kickoff return. The last six Tennessee drives, not counting the one that concluded the game, resulted in 291 yds. on 48 plays, five touchdowns and a FG.

2006 georgia lost to vanderbilt and kentucky

it should rank right up there with the florida win in 1970

:)
 
#24
#24
2006 georgia lost to vanderbilt and kentucky

it should rank right up there with the florida win in 1970

:)

Yes and I am thoroughly convinced that losing to us the way that they did left the '06 Georgia team ripe to be upset by Vanderbilt. In any event, mitigating factors are why these games do not make the cut for poll selection purposes.

As for comparisons to the 1970 game, I watched them both and our victory over Florida in that game was a more thoroughly dominating performance than our win over Georgia in 2006.
 
#25
#25
WebbVol32, Casey was a true road warrior but the most rewarding aspect of the '01 Florida game, given our status as huge underdogs, was that we absolutely whipped them up front and mauled them with our running game.
I concur. Travis Stephens was the star that night along with the big uglies who dominated the LOS on both offence and defence. I never wouldve thought Stephens would be able to compete in the SEC given his small stature. He was not only competitive but dominant. Clausen was undefeated in the state of Florida. He captained the Vols to very impressive road wins over the Gators and Canes. Without his poise and leadership,who knows what the outcomes would've been. GO VOLS!
 

VN Store



Back
Top