Ranking the first year coaches...

#1

NCGatorBait

VN GURU
Joined
Dec 12, 2003
Messages
9,800
Likes
0
#1
Click Here


Am I the only one that doesn't think Weiss should be #2? He only beat like two ranked teams all yr..right?

Zooker comes in near the bottom of the list...surprised he was even mentioned.


 
#4
#4
Weis is definitely having one of the great honeymoons of all time.
 
#6
#6
(NCGatorBait @ Jan 16 said:
Hey bro...move this if you want to..just thought it might get some chatter.





Notre Dame -Weis #1. LSU and the Gators were loaded with talent.Time will tell.
 
#7
#7
(NCGatorBait @ Jan 16 said:
Hey bro...move this if you want to..just thought it might get some chatter.

No problem . . . I think it's a good topic. Plus, right now, I'm leaving it here just because I can. :D
 
#8
#8
Miles and Weis did well, but my vote goes to Spurrier. He inherited a team that had nobody with any experience running, throwing or catching the football and somehow milked a productive offense out of them. If Holtz had stayed, I would have bet that team would have won 4 games.
 
#9
#9
(utfantilidie @ Jan 16 said:
Notre Dame -Weis #1. LSU and the Gators were loaded with talent.Time will tell.


Loaded talent doesnt always translate to loaded for a new type of system though)IE Leak running the spread option)..if I ranked them:


1 Spurrier
2 Miles (UM game gave him an edge over Meyer)
3 Meyer
4 Weiss
 
#11
#11
I'm a little tired of the Weis hype but from the looks of that list, there wasn't much competition!

Kind of makes you wonder about what great coaches are available out there if a hypothetical coach that had a great winning percentage and an NC on a hypothetical team was to hypothetically get fired... :ninja:

Oh crap, I just screwed up the thread
:birgits_giggle:
 
#12
#12
Weiss did pretty well, but he only played 4 teams with winning records. Against them he went 2-2. It doesn't seem to me that such a year is quite as good as advertised when ND's big wins are a close one over a subpar Michigan team (even more subpar because Mike Hart didn't play) and Navy. Also, I think when Michigan fumbled at the goal line and one of ND's guys recovered, it looked like that was a load of crap. I don't see how that call was supported by any of the video evidence. I don't know if everyone remembers that play, but it was a pivotal moment, where Michigan could have driven it in to score, and probably would have resulted in a UM win. ND also lost to a Michigan State team that got embarrassed by a lot of bad teams this year.

Weiss is a good coach, but I think a lot of other teams would have been able to go undefeated facing their schedule. Ah well, we'll see how good he is next year.
 
#13
#13
i would feel better about Miles being no. 1 had he beaten UGA in the SEC CG...but all said, they did hav a good year, despite all the stuff that happened...but they do have a bunch of talent, and the smartest thing Miles did all year was keep the coordinators....so there was a smooth transisiton for the players....

I would have ranked Spurrier #1, no body did more with less than he did....he beat UF for the first time and beat UT for the first time in Knoxville...both firsts for South Carolina, or at least, first time a very, very long time....

Weis, well, i'll say this. THat ND team played much, much better than anyone anticipated. Even with the schedule being what it was, you can't deny the development of that offensive team. all the skill people got, it seemed, instantly better than last year.

Meyer gets a lot of credit for beating his natural rivals, which will keep the hounds off him....beat FSU, UGA and TN in the same year, regardless of how good or bad those three are, and you're doing something, plus two of those teams won their conf....not too shabby. but he doesn't get credit for not changing the offensive scheme earlier in the season. It was so obvious that the offense was struggling with his system, and when you got C. Leak, the supposed golden arm of the SEC, you should tailor the scheme to your talent's ability...sounds familiar right?

for me, it would have been:
Spurrier
Miles
Weiss
Meyer
 

VN Store



Back
Top