This QB "discussion" is really all about what type of offense you personally want to see.
Dobbs, or somebody highly mobile like him, was necessary to win games during much of the time he was here. The type O Butch ran with the limited offensive line made it necessary. Add in that Malone was not Malone until last season. Dobbs' limitations also made the O be what it was.
Many on here like the classic pro-style QB that has mobility. Guess what, both QD and JG are those guys. JG is not a DT, Ainge has pointed that out numerous times. He better not be because he will get broken in half with his physique. Dobbs is much stronger physically than JG even though JG is quicker. JG has more mobility than QD, but he is not DT. There are good reasons OC Scott is modifying the O. One of the major ones in addition to building a more diverse offense that is harder to defend, is that the QB's are mobile pro-style and not DT.
The actual performance in practices and games will determine who wins the job. But accepting the abilities of who you have and the offensive scheme is more than half the battle for fans. Whoever handles the offense the best, has the confidence of the other players and coaches, is more accurate, and is quicker with correct thinking will win out. If it is the guy that runs the ball the best, we are in trouble. That means the O-line stinks and we are not passing well.
