Guarantano isn't leaving for one year at a rebuilding from the septic tank Rutgers when he could be (at worst) the #2 QB on what may well be a solid '20 Vols team. If he has any NFL aspirations at all, Queens College is not the place to find them. Knoxville? Maybe.
And it wouldn't hurt for us to have that depth next year, as we already know Maurer will jump into a woodchipper if he thinks if will get one more yard. HB is legit, but he'll likely need a year to come up to SEC speed. Depth at QB is a nice problem to have in November. Just ask Saban.
I've had my issues with JG, but he came off the bench to win the UK game. That, and he's taken more beatings over the last two seasons than the long list of Mike Tyson's opponents over the years. Talent might be limited, but that kid has the heart of a lion. I'd rather have him on our roster than not, given where we are right now.
I think he stays, as he should.
Go Vols.