shirley or luc

[UTDreamTeam#22#25]

whos better josh shirley or jeff luc and does anybody know anything about if mccay is as good as advertised

 

[aaronvol]

I live here in Kansas...McCay...overrated.

Luc...that guy is for real. Will be a monster on the field.

 

[Volholla]

I would be extremely happy with either, both in terms of landing one or two big recruits, who would lead to connections in SoCal and Florida.

W/ that said.. I prefer Luc, just based on his head hunting ability. However, I love the closing speed Shirley has getting to the ball.

I live in KC,Mo, close to Shawnee (Where McCay is from), Ive never seen him play live, but I do know that the competition he is facing there is no where near what he would be in Florida, Georgia, Cali, etc.... With that said, the competition isn't bad.

Rivals lists McCay at about 6'3, but in the newspapers back home it has him at 6'4-6'5. I think that alone, with a 4.5 forty is worthy of a spot on the team. Should develop into a mighty fine receiver, but I wouldn't say elite

 

[VolsFanRJ]

Based off the videos alone, I would have to say Luc. He's a beast.

 

[oldvol61]

I think luc will grow into a def end before he done in collage.

 

[matts42012]

Luc may have the problem of getting too big to be a LB. I think both will be good players in college.

 

[Sabanocchio]

I think luc will grow into a def end before he done in collage.

I think that might suit his skill set better.


I'll take Shirley. I think he's a better all around LB.