Taunting penalty

[LIvol]

Shane Beamer calls out officials for decision in final seconds, reveals he sent multiple plays to SEC office

South Carolina coach Shane Beamer was not happy with the officiating in a 36-33 home loss against LSU on Saturday.

www.on3.com

Is taunting after the play a dead ball foul or is he looking to replay the down?

Just curious... if it's a dead ball then who cares if you get a bunch of 15 yrders when the game is over.

 

[OrangeVolMan]

Shane said it was after the play. So I believe you are correct.

 

[LouderVol]

If it's after the clock hit zero it's just a deadball foul, game over. Kinda like the Bama player taking his helmet off when he blocked our FG with Kiffin.

 

[GrayWaterCanine]

Shane Beamer calls out officials for decision in final seconds, reveals he sent multiple plays to SEC office

South Carolina coach Shane Beamer was not happy with the officiating in a 36-33 home loss against LSU on Saturday.

www.on3.com

Is taunting after the play a deadbolt foul or is he looking to replay the down?

Just curious... if it's a deadbolt then who cares if you get a bunch of 15 yrders when the game is over.

You can't take a penalty in that situation. It's a lock.

 

[GAVol]

If it's after the clock hit zero it's just a deadball foul, game over. Kinda like the Bama player taking his helmet off when he blocked our FG with Kiffin.

Don’t get me started on that one 15 years later. The blocked kick was still rolling around on the ground when Cody took his helmet off and half the Alabama bench came onto the field. I don’t know that it would’ve been a re-kick but it was ridiculous that nobody flagged it.

 

[LibertyVol]

Don’t get me started on that one 15 years later. The blocked kick was still rolling around on the ground when Cody took his helmet off and half the Alabama bench came onto the field. I don’t know that it would’ve been a re-kick but it was ridiculous that nobody flagged it.

It was Alabama. When I watch Alabama I am almost shocked when the refs call a penalty on them. It is ridiculous.

 

[bamawriter]

Don’t get me started on that one 15 years later. The blocked kick was still rolling around on the ground when Cody took his helmet off and half the Alabama bench came onto the field. I don’t know that it would’ve been a re-kick but it was ridiculous that nobody flagged it.

Good grief. An unsportsmanlike conduct penalty is enforced as a dead ball foul even if it occurs during a live ball situation. So, the result of the play stands and then a penalty is assessed. In the case of Cody removing his helmet, the play resulted in Alabama's possession AND the end of the game. Thus, there was nothing to enforce. Complaining about a lack of a flag for a penalty that would have been utterly meaningless is the sourest of grapes.

And before someone says that taunting is enforced as a live ball penalty: it's a stretch to argue that Cody was taunting anyone. And it's completely irrelevant since the change to the taunting penalty was done before the 2011 season.

 

[MHS Rebel]

If it's after the clock hit zero it's just a deadball foul, game over. Kinda like the Bama player taking his helmet off when he blocked our FG with Kiffin.

The ball was still in the field of play and rolling around.
Just like a punt is is not done until a member of the punt team touches it or the ball comes to a rest. We saw just recently where a punt was still kinda rocking on the ground and a member of the return team picked it up and ran. The punt team was standing around watching it come to a rest.

 

[GAVol]

Good grief. An unsportsmanlike conduct penalty is enforced as a dead ball foul even if it occurs during a live ball situation. So, the result of the play stands and then a penalty is assessed. In the case of Cody removing his helmet, the play resulted in Alabama's possession AND the end of the game. Thus, there was nothing to enforce. Complaining about a lack of a flag for a penalty that would have been utterly meaningless is the sourest of grapes.

And before someone says that taunting is enforced as a live ball penalty: it's a stretch to argue that Cody was taunting anyone. And it's completely irrelevant since the change to the taunting penalty was done before the 2011 season.

I’ll bet that’s why I ended the post with:

I don’t know that it would’ve been a re-kick but it was ridiculous that nobody flagged it.

The replay looks ridiculous with the ball rolling around and players running everywhere.

 

[bamawriter]

I’ll bet that’s why I ended the post with:



The replay looks ridiculous with the ball rolling around and players running everywhere.

Agreed. That's why I think it's absurd to complain that a flag wasn't thrown. Of the 22 players and 8 officials on the field, only 3 or 4 were even aware that the ball was still live.

 

[adam.vol]

Agreed. That's why I think it's absurd to complain that a flag wasn't thrown. Of the 22 players and 8 officials on the field, only 3 or 4 were even aware that the ball was still live.

Kiffin really had those boys well drilled and ready for anything.

What a joke..