The OP is correct. Hopson played great vs. Villanova and Pitt and we win. He disappears for most of the game vs. Oakland and Charlotte and we lose. IMO, we only have 4 legit players on this team (Hopson, Tatum, Goins, and Harris). You can maybe throw Maybin in there later. These are the players that will score points and if they are not getting it done, we can lose to anyone. After these 4-5 we have a bunch of role players. We may play alot of players but that doesn't mean we are deep.
The predictions of final fours, best UT team ever, 25-3 records, lose less than 5 games, etc. are not happening.