Well, why didn't you put in a claim?
I don't think Kevin Smith is going to continue to light it up. Hell, CJ2ypc put up similar numbers against Carolina. He didn't get the scores, so his fantasy score didn't even approach that, but if CJ puts up more than 40 yds total on you this year, you're a bad defense.
I picked him up as a wait-and-see prospect if I get into the playoffs, but you can't complain, because you obviously didn't put in a claim, otherwise your league has some messed up waiver order protocol.