Underrated three-stars

[Coach Punk]

Three-Point Stance: Underrated three-stars, Penn State, 2018 notes

DE Matthew Butler, Tennessee – He could grow into a defensive tackle or stay at end. He could be tough to handle if he gets a bit more sudden.

I'm not saying they blew a lot of the rankings....but I am saying this year looked whackier than most.

And courtesy tonybologna:

Under the Radar Recruits

 

[OGbabyaviVol]

Why not just put this in the Butler thread, instead of making a new thread for it?

 

[Bassmaster_Vol]

add Pagr, Labruzza, Bailey, Bennett and Shamburger to that list also

 

[livefaith]

All our 3 stars are going to be like Can Sutton.
/End thread

 

[Big Gucci Sosa]

All our 3 stars are going to be like Can Sutton.
/End thread

This

 

[BondJamesBond]

Some of them will be. If enough of them are, then we spend 2019 applauding CBJs ability to spot talent. I'm hopeful.

 

[volroadwarrior]

All our 3 stars are going to be like Can Sutton.
/End thread

Negavols gonna git u if u don't watch out.:machgun:

 

[volnbama_]

Our 3 stars have 5 stars hearts and bleed orange. You can't put a star ranking on that

 

[utvolmaniac]

All our 3 stars are going to be like Can Sutton.
/End thread

Yeah!

 

[bignewt]

Our 3 stars have 5 stars hearts and bleed orange. You can't put a star ranking on that

Why are all vol fans in bama insufferable? Hold on too tight?

 

[goldvol]

All our 3 stars are going to be like Can Sutton.
/End thread

What is it like canned? Need to open it up and let him loose. ilot:

 

[shelbyvillevol]

Our 3 stars have 5 stars hearts and bleed orange. You can't put a star ranking on that

Yes you can. 8 Stars. Simple math.

 

[Coach Punk]

add Pagr, Labruzza, Bailey, Bennett and Shamburger to that list also

Yeah, that's where the services where all over the map. Not a lot of concensus on the grades.

 

[HollowaytoSeivers]

Why are all vol fans in bama insufferable? Hold on too tight?

Don't be too hard on them. I lived in Kentucky during the Wade Houston era in hoops. Football season was the only time I had any peace. Living in enemy territory requires scraping for any advantage (however insignificant) you can get.

 

[Bring_Back_Dooley]

our 3 stars have 5 stars hearts and bleed orange. You can't put a star ranking on that

lol

 

[butchna]

Why are all vol fans in bama insufferable? Hold on too tight?

"Some things ain't TIGHT no more!" inch:

-anonymous Bama survivor resident.

 

[Catbone]

Ahem... not saying Butler won't be a beast but...3 debunked recruiting myths that prove Signing Day is crucial | FOX Sports

 

[3rdDegreeVol]

"some things ain't tight no more!" inch:

-anonymous bama survivor resident.

twss?

 

[butchna]

twss?

Or h or i.

 

[Grudenator]

Ahem... not saying Butler won't be a beast but...3 debunked recruiting myths that prove Signing Day is crucial | FOX Sports

Rule number 1. Don't bring actual facts or realistic opinions on this board.

 

[LouderVol]

Ahem... not saying Butler won't be a beast but...3 debunked recruiting myths that prove Signing Day is crucial | FOX Sports

some of the points in that article are really broad.

#5 is better than #35, no isht. no one is arguing that. we were from #11 to #17 hardly 35.

then they measure success two different ways using two different metrics. Rankings vs NFL success and rankings vs individual college success. neither of which directly relates to college team success, what we ultimately care about. NFL success is completely separate from the matter at hand. the other metric they use is All American or starter. you can easily have 5* starters who don't amount to much and they would count that as success.

and lastly they go over recruiting rankings with 12 of the top 20 recruiters being in the Top 20 AP rankings. is this Anchorman? 60% of the time it works every time? it also ignores a lot of outside factors like coaching changes and the like. Kiffins highly rated classes did jack because they disappeared.

if they really wanted to prove the benefit of signing day mattering they would reevaluate their rankings down the road. If 6 5 stars are in your class and never play a down and you still end up ranked high they say that proves their case, when in reality it doesn't. and they could also get more specific than saying #5 is better than #35 and here is the proof. why not show that #5 is better than #15, or 10 or 8? the reason they dont is probably because it is way too much work and there are other factors that goes beyond the stars. and the fact that Bama hasn't won every single national championship during their run of #1s. especially as it was an average recruiting ranking of #11 or so that beat #1 Bama.

stars matter, to a point.

 

[volnbama_]

Why are all vol fans in bama insufferable? Hold on too tight?

Probably because of our uncle fathers

 

[bignewt]

Probably because of our uncle fathers

+1 for sense of humour and i love sunny...i need more dayman out of you.

 

[volinbama256]

Some of them will be. If enough of them are, then we spend 2019 applauding CBJs ability to spot talent. I'm hopeful.

He may be able to spot it, but developing it is another story...

 

[TennMan101]

He may be able to spot it, but developing it is another story...

CBJ is not the only one responsible for developing our players! That's why we have position coaches! LOL at the ignorance or just plain hating on CBJ for Player Development.