What would you do?

[CSpindizzy]

Would you bench the following?

A)Throws the same amount of TDs as INTs, QB rating has never gone above 81 and averages 76% for the past few years, completion rate is 54%, averages at least 1 fumble per game, slightly less than one INT per game, one passing TD per game, 150 yards passing a game

B)overall rating of 87%, this year as many INTs as TDs, alomst average 2 INTs per game

C)QB average of 88% for past few years, this year average 94%, averaging one INT per game

D)One INT per game this year, QB rating of 88 with career average of 84%

E)Past 4 games: no TD's 4 INTs, QB rating of 58%

F)Career passing percentage at 49%, career QB rating of 68%, approximately 1 to 1 TD to INT ratio, one INT per game, slightly more than one TD per game

 

[Liper]

I'll play along, but may I ask for a couple of things...

1. stats need to be uniform
2. need more stats

There aren't enough stats to make any kind of valid evaluation.

2005 stats needed

1.comp%
2.TD
3.INT
4.pass rating
5.comp
6.attempts
7.yards

 

[CSpindizzy]

Unless it says overall or career these are 2005 stats. Forgive the lack of uniformity. I don;t have time to organize the info. I'm offering some of the same criteria that has been posted on verious topics already covered. I just wanted to see with those stats who gets bounced under each person's own definitions.