Which officiating crew got it wrong?

#1

KoachKrab127

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2009
Messages
4,761
Likes
5,551
#1
Yesterday, two very similar plays happened in the FLA/Arky game and the LSU/Bama game, and the referees made rulings that were contradicting. I was wondering if someone could help me understand which crew got it wrong, or if there is some exception that I don’t understand. Here’s what happened.

At the end of regulation during the Florida game, the Gators got a first down with 8 seconds left, tackled in bounds, no timeouts left. They then received a penalty for illegal substitution as all the players and coaches panicked before the final snap. The refs ruled that there would be no 10 second runoff because the Gators got a first down on the previous play and the clock was stopped. Instead, the ref said he would spot the ball, then start the clock on his whistle.

Well, in the LSU game at the end of the first half, LSU got a first down and was tackled in bounds. They had one timeout left. They did not call timeout, but got called for a false start. The ref said that LSU elected to take their final timeout rather than have a 10 second runoff. So why did LSU have to burn a timeout to avoid a 10 second runoff, but Florida did not have a 10 second runoff when they were out of timeouts? Which crew was wrong? Or is there something I’m missing? Thanks to anyone who tries to help me understand, because I was extremely frustrated trying to figure this out yesterday.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orangebloodgmc
#2
#2
Great question. I watched both games and had the same question. My guess is that LSU game was right because if not you could just commit a quick penalty to stop the clock in that situation.

I have nothing to base that on rule wise.
 
#3
#3
It’s baffling to me that more people haven’t been talking about this. I mean, we all love to talk about how awful the refs are. This is a clear demonstration of the refs not knowing the rules. I can’t believe more people aren’t pointing this out.
 
#4
#4
The Refs in the Fla game got it wrong in multiple ways. It should have been a 10 second run off since the clock would have started once the 1st down markers were set and Fla had no time outs left OR the Refs should have stood over the ball to allow the defense (Ark) to substitute after the offense (Fla) did. Ark could have easily run the clock out getting their players on the field.

Luckily the Fla kicker missed the game winning FG so he bailed out the Refs extremely bad call.
 
#5
#5
The Refs in the Fla game got it wrong in multiple ways. It should have been a 10 second run off since the clock would have started once the 1st down markers were set and Fla had no time outs left OR the Refs should have stood over the ball to allow the defense (Ark) to substitute after the offense (Fla) did. Ark could have easily run the clock out getting their players on the field.

Luckily the Fla kicker missed the game winning FG so he bailed out the Refs extremely bad call.
Yes, poetic justice.
Officials absolutely blew that call in the FLA-ARK game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KoachKrab127
#6
#6
The Refs in the Fla game got it wrong in multiple ways. It should have been a 10 second run off since the clock would have started once the 1st down markers were set and Fla had no time outs left OR the Refs should have stood over the ball to allow the defense (Ark) to substitute after the offense (Fla) did. Ark could have easily run the clock out getting their players on the field.

Luckily the Fla kicker missed the game winning FG so he bailed out the Refs extremely bad call.

Yeah, the ref stood over the ball for about 2 seconds to allow Arky to sub. Normally they give a team at least 10-15 seconds.

What I thought was even dumber was the Arkansas coach taking a timeout after that ref fiasco. The refs said, “The clock will start on my whistle,” meaning he’d spot the ball, then back up, blow the whistle, and the clock would start before the snap. So the Florida kicking team would need to be very quick to get the kick off on time. The Arkansas coach allowed them to settle down and kick the FG at a relaxed pace. He still missed it, but at the time, I was baffled that Arkansas stopped the clock for Florida like that.
 

VN Store



Back
Top