2004 Peyton Manning -vs- 2007 Tom Brady

[golfballs]

you throw that many times, and you're going to have more TDs.

Peyton was a better QB

 

[HSVol]

you throw that many times, and you're going to have more TDs.

Peyton was a better QB

More attempts don't necessarily equate to more TDs. PM threw around 675 times last season and didn't come close to 40 TDs.

However, I had never considered the notion that PM would still have the TD record had he played the final game vs the Broncos that year, but now that it has been mentioned, I'm convinced he would still have that record.

Either way, Rodgers and/or Brady will break Brady's record this year.

 

[Vol423]

Either way, Rodgers and/or Brady will break Brady's record this year.

Highly doubtful.

 

[ENGRVOL]

not to mention peyton sat more during the season. I think he didn't even play the last game that year

This, though that 2007 Patriots team was pretty special. If NE wins the superbowl then this conversation is over. Rodgers is good but he is not as important to his team as Manning is. When he was out last year to injury against the Patriots Matt Flynn (who never really impressed me that much in college) walked in and threw for 250 yds and 3 TDs.

 

[golfballs]

This, though that 2007 Patriots team was pretty special. If NE wins the superbowl then this conversation is over. Rodgers is good but he is not as important to his team as Manning is. When he was out last year to injury against the Patriots Matt Flynn (who never really impressed me that much in college) walked in and threw for 250 yds and 3 TDs.

Super bowl wins are a team accomplishment not a measure of a QB
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[005]

Super bowl wins are a team accomplishment not a measure of a QB
Posted via VolNation Mobile

Precisely