I would only agree BruinVol if it was a big event every year and the years in the future will tell. I would agree from past experience with guys I have coached and friends of my sons that there are guys who leave all schools every year for various reasons. I don't think it is over recruiting as much as it is the writing on the wall and getting out before missing a year of playing. I think that players/parents can see by the players that are coming in, whether freshmen or juco transfers that there will not be a place for them. Some of them go to the coach and have a conversation and some just know. There are also some that are not realistic or where they are is their dream school so they will stay and hope they make it or will stay just because they want to play there or nowhere. The top level kids don't worry about it because they know when they commit/go to a top school that they have to compete with their teammates before they get to compete with the other teams in the SEC. I tell mine every week that "you have to compete to wear the T before you can compete to defend the T". (Side note: that would make a great T-shirt). I don't usually hear of coaches coming to players and telling them to leave but the players seeing it or knowing where they are in the pecking order. Mine is there and I want them to win but I also know that it is the coaching staff's job to recruit the best players they can every year as incoming freshmen and juco players. If mine falls down the depth chart, he can either work harder to move back up, transfer, or stay and hope things change. Not the coaches fault for doing his job good. Now if he is recruiting more players than he has scholarships, then that is a problem. But recruiting more than he can carry is not in my opinion. His job is to get the best players to wear a T on their chest.
I also realize next year this time I may be thinking something different but I don't think so because we/my son went into this thing with open eyes. He knows how tough it will be to get playing time in the pitching rotation or batting order as an incoming freshman but that is his desire and knows he will have to work hard to earn it. On a side note, I do not know of any that are leaving that are expected to come back. There is a couple that were supposed to come that de-committed for various reasons and I don't perceive any as over recruiting. Seems a couple that are not coming were for the same position and saw the writing on the wall. Both made good choices for themselves.