2021 College World Series Game Discussion Thread: Bracket 1 and Bracket 2 (excluding Tennessee)

I agree with this part of it. Telling the catcher straight down 3rd is not necessary and not his place. Pitches? Cool. Where the ball goes after that? Not cool.
Has anyone seen this before? I sure haven't. Seems way out of line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zues1
Has anyone seen this before? I sure haven't. Seems way out of line.
Never. Never heard this much on the pitches either. I’m ok with it but playing through HS may have heard a couple pitches a game where the ump said outside or low but not to this extent.
 
Let's look at this scenario. The winning run is on third base, nice lead.
Catcher misses/ drops the ball. Runner is coming, he can't locate the ball.
This umpire says it's right here, right here. Catcher picks it up, tags out the runner game over?

I get where you’re coming from, but the catcher wasn’t part of the play in this case. Like I said, if it was the catcher’s ball it wouldn’t have happened.
 
Never. Never heard this much on the pitches either. I’m ok with it but playing through HS may have heard a couple pitches a game where the ump said outside or low but not to this extent.
Yep, he is too involved.
Officiating as part of sports, but you don't need to be seen or heard until necessary.
Is the first base ump telling the first baseman where the ball is, or position he needs to be in. No.
 
I get where you’re coming from, but the catcher wasn’t part of the play in this case. Like I said, if it was the catcher’s ball it wouldn’t have happened.
How can we be sure though? He’s used to commenting on almost every pitch (beyond simply calling balls and strikes) that perhaps he slips up and blurts out where a ball is that directly impacts a play.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GhostVol and Zues1
Has anyone seen this before? I sure haven't. Seems way out of line.

I caught and that’s why I spoke up. Its definitely not common, but I’m not surprised from my own experiences. Umpires that are more of the controlling type are the ones that chat and are edgy. This guy seems thorough af.
 
I get where you’re coming from, but the catcher wasn’t part of the play in this case. Like I said, if it was the catcher’s ball it wouldn’t have happened.
With this umpire, I think it might. He can't see to stay quiet.
 
Yep, he is too involved.
Officiating as part of sports, but you don't need to be seen or heard until necessary.
Is the first base ump telling the first baseman where the ball is, or position he needs to be in. No.
Great, Vandy gets the sympathetic, helpful ump, we’ll get the A-hole, with the erratic strike zone tomorrow.
GBO!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: GhostVol and Zues1
I caught and that’s why I spoke up. Its definitely not common, but I’m not surprised from my own experiences. Umpires that are more of the controlling type are the ones that chat and are edgy. This guy seems thorough af.
As a catcher for 18 years I never had an umpire "help" any situation. Balls and strikes only. maybe an argument now and then but no help in any way. I think it is not his job and is not appropraite.
 

VN Store



Back
Top