Not quite sure what you were watching, but Nkahmoua NEVER played the 3 for Tennessee last year, literally not a single second. He did however play quite a bit of 5, and yes, started every single game while healthy at the 4 spot. He played more minutes up to the point of his injury than any other big guy on our roster, and again a large bulk of that was coming at the 5 spot…there was actually tons of dicusssion about this as our best lineups per advanced metrics were routinely with Nkahmoua at the 5.
Point taken! I put in the 3 part because I did not remember which position on the floor ON had when JJJ was out and did not bother to look it up.
You are right, he is definitely not a 3 - he is just not a threat as he gets further from the basket. I did not intend to imply that he played the 3, sorry.
As regards, him playing the 5, specifically in small ball situations.... I felt that was more to do with Fulky and Uros inadequacies rather than specifically to do with Olivier's skills. However, I will absolutely acknowledge that ON was the BEST fit for small ball as he appears to be 'faster' than Uros and his endurance was far superior to Fulky.
And yes there was a ton of discussion about small ball ... but that small ball success was always
after substitutions and backup players hit the floor. Our small ball was better than the other teams 2nd team and backups.
However, I do not remember one single instance of us coming out and starting the game in small ball. We just did not do it!
Note: Respectfully, you are mistaken on 'played
more minutes up to the point of his injury than any other big guy on our roster' - Fulky averaged 22.4 going into the SC game and Olivier averaged 21.7.
I know that it felt like Olivier was playing more minutes, I was curious about this so I took the time to look it up .... but it is contrary to the the actual facts.
I think that we were so happy with the results of the small ball (and I am including me here) ... that some thought it would work for the whole game .... and thus those people on the floor during small ball were our 'better' players. And I believe that is also why is seemed like Olivier played more minutes. What I think we actually did was substitute him out to rest him and then brought him back in for the small ball runs.
I am more of a systems kind of guy, where you look at the big picture. I thought our strategy was to 'tire the other team out.' We did that by pushing the tempo the entire game. That resulted in our small ball being more effective against 'tired' 1st string players and fresh 2nd stringers. That is my guess as an outsider - because I have no connections to anyone on UT's coaching staff. I think the success of our small ball was a by-product of success at doing other things. I reached this conclusion because we did
not choose to start games in small ball.
“Small ball” is the most successful style almost exclusively in college basketball, you rarely find many successful teams playing twin towers in the post. Yes there are some, but your mindset seems to be stuck in the style of 5+ years ago, that is no longer the case. Again, there was tons of discussions about this last year, when we were hitting our stride it was when we started playing more small ball and Nkahmoua was playing a bulk of his minutes at the 5.
You are right about the small ball discussion. I remember it well. However, you are wrong about me - I am not a twin towers guy.
I am more of a John Wooden kind of guy. Or a Coach K kind of guy. I absolutely do believe you need an effective big man on the floor and for me 6'8" is a little bit small for an effective big man.
I think you can win a lot of games playing small ball. Auburn did it really well a couple of years ago. But to go deep and win in tournaments, specifically the NCAA, I look at the kind of team that won a lot of championships like Coach K or Coach W put on the floor. They were able to run up and down the floor and push the tempo and they had a big man (6'10"+) as well. So, they could play multiple styles to beat a variety of teams.
In my opinion, the reason that there is so much small ball in college is because the vast majority of college teams do not have an
effective 6'10"+ big man on their roster.
According to me, we did
not have an effective nor dominant big man on the floor last season. I was hoping that Fulky (at 6'9" not really a big man in my book - does not have the big springs, he out-quicked the defender in his prime) would return to form, but he never got back to his peak (Ky game) after his injury.
Like you I’m not saying he won’t ever play the 4, he will, but if last year is any sort of sign and if Phillips & Key are both as good as expected to be then we will once again be playing a lot of small ball and Nkahmoua will almost certainly once again be our leading big man in MPG.
In this regard, we agree!!! I am absolutely hoping that Phillips & Key are as good as their hype. But regardless, we will again play a lot of small ball and ON will get a ton of minutes at the 5 ( hoping for an injury free year for him). I am betting that SV and JJJ actually lead the team in MPG. Who has the most MPG from the 4/5 group will depend a lot on Phillips, in my opinion. Does he back up ON at the 4 or does he back up JJJ at the 3 or does he play some of both? I've seen that he compares his game to Jason Tatum and Paul George. I've seen the video and he can shoot from 3, but he likes to drive to the basket. He does
not look to score from 3.
Note: I am still of the opinion that ON starts at the 4 ..... so I am guessing that Phillips starts out backing up ON at the 4, but he will extremely effective in the small ball game at either the 3 or the 4. The open question for me is how much effort coaches put into developing his shot from 3 so that he can also play the 3 behind JJJ. My take: Barnes likes to get as much height as he can get at the 3.