If I am recalling correctly, Reese was not eligible for the POY award because she had not met academic requirements. That was on her, and on Kim and her staff, for not having a handle on her academic situation.
Reese, IMO, doesn't have as "pretty" a post game as Boston, but there are few post players today who give more effort, or have more determination to succeed, than Reese. She is an absolute dog on the court, and always finds a way to GSD. Gotta respect that!
Yes, many of her rebounds are multiple put-backs after she's thrown shots toward the basket and missed, but that she does that is really beside the point. Her methods are a bit unorthodox, but her results are undeniably successful. And since the No. 1 goal is to finish each game than more points than the opponent, it doesn't have to look pretty as long as it works. Reese gets hers.
I believe most people here probably feel the same as I do. Nobody can deny she's a big-time player, and one of the most consistently effective in the game today.