cncchris33
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2009
- Messages
- 34,289
- Likes
- 51,682
But it's still year over year improvement after a tenure that never saw him win an NCAAT game.He's a known seller in the postseason. Those teams at Marquette were far too talented to exit when they did each year.
First round exit (2021-22) - Justin Lewis (17ppg/8rpg), Darryl Morsey (13 ppg), Kam Jones, Tyler Kolek, Olivier-Maxence Prosper, Oso Ighodaro
Second round exit (2022-23) - Jones, Kolek, OMP, Oso
Sweet 16 exit (2023-24) - same team but no OMP. However Kam Jones and Tyler Kolek continued their quick development and turned into two of the best guards in the country
Those last two years were arguably a top 5 team and played one second weekend game. Let's add some context to those numbers. I get Kolek was dealing with injuries but still. Then like you said he already followed Barnes once in a major job and failed to even win a tournament game. He's better as the underdog in a job with less pressure it seems like
And with that 2021 team (his first team), especially, it seems like you're giving a lot of misplaced credit to the kind of players those guys would become, not who they were at the time as freshmen and sophomores. Kam Jones, Tyler Kolek, Olivier-Maxence Prosper, Oso Ighodaro...all those guys were contributors (Kolek in particular), but not really the studs they later became. They averaged a combined 26 ppg, 11 rpg, 9 apg. Certainly nothing to sneeze at or discount, but split amongst 85 combine minutes.
My point is that if the expectation is that when Barnes hangs it up, that we will hire someone with more combined experience, recognition, and credentials than Shaka Smart, I think people are likely in for a rude awakening. If you could guarantee me we'd get him, I'd take it immediately, because in all likelihood, we will do much worse in at least one of the bolded areas. It doesn't mean that coach will be a worse coach, but there will be a lot of risk involved, and I've lived far long enough to see Tennessee butcher it's fair share of coaching hires in attempt to go cheap and/or find lightning in a bottle. It's a gamble.