Firstly, kiddiedoc got this thread started off right! Kudos to you, sir.
To AC's question, I started the thread on mobile and didn't want to type a ton. So, here's my acoustic history:
In 1999 I traded a bass for a '98 Taylor 612CE with the Fishman system. I got the guitar for my wife (then girlfriend) who was a singer/songwriter in Nashville at the time. She played it on some sessions, then it went into the case for the better part of a decade and a half once we left the music industry.
A few years ago, I began playing acoustic on the 612. I've since written a number of songs on it - a few for my wife, one for my oldest daughter, among others. It plays PHENOMENALLY... the action is very low, which suits my style well.
Since then, I've gone down the road of curiosity and picked up a used Martin OMJM (about a year ago) which sounds great and I love the 1 11/16 nut. Then, last month bought a 1993 Santa Cruz OM. The thing has seen some abuse, but what a guitar! The tone is mesmerizing, and the neck is the most comfortable depth.
I'll be selling the OMJM, I believe. I'll play the SC a bit longer before deciding its fate. I may end up custom ordering one like this one but with the OMJM nut width.
The Taylor will stay here. I actually prefer the tone of the other two guitars for most applications. The 612 doesn't have much girth, is very shimmery, which makes for nice fingerpicking, but I like the rosewood OM vibe more. But as kiddiedoc perfectly articulated, this Taylor has seen the best and worst of times.
The only one I've got pictures of is the Martin.