rjd970
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2007
- Messages
- 24,298
- Likes
- 24,325
No one makes promises. Offers from the school are as binding as verbal commitments are from the kids. It's a harsh game.
Nick Saban has always been a proponent of an early signing period, but other coaches, ADs, and presidents around the country have shot it down. If there had been an early signing period, and Justin Taylor had signed then, then he'd be at Alabama right now, or Bama might never have made an offer to him in the hopes that another player would sign later. It's wrong to hate on Saban for doing this when he proposed an alternative. He's playing by the same rules as everyone else.
Sure, but saban could have told him where he really stands, no? Nothing wrong with being honest with a kid. "hey, we will accept your commitment, but just to let you know we are recruiting a couple other guys at your position we would take. It may be good to have a couple other options in place in case we can't give you a scholarship".
Simple, honest, direct, and the kid knows exactly where he stands. For a coach making $4 mil plus per year, it should be his responsibility to plan better instead of griping about signing periods or assuming an 18 year old kid knows better.