I agree with 100% of what you said.
To add to what you said, fans can usually tell who was raised by good parents, Brandon Knight was the valedictorian if his high school and carried a 4.0 while at UK...then you have guys like Daniel Orton who give up...I don't care that you're stupid, I do care that you give up.
However, as you said thats a part of it when you recruit athlete above student.
I have a lot of respect for guys (at any school) who leave to make money and come back to finish their education. Im sure there are lots of UT examples I just dont know any of them.
And I would LOVE the MLB rule if for nothing else it would allow me to get to know my team better year-to-year
it sucks getting attached to a group only to never see them again.