I AM being honest. He's a 35 year old coach who's had a head coaching job for 4 years. He's had a lofty won/lost record each year. He's had a lot of talent but with as much talent there are problem players. He's at least been able to sort those out and eventually fix them. They've had some good wins (maybe not top 25 at the time of the win) but beat Xavier in '12 who was later ranked top 25. Beat Gonzaga at their place. The win @ Tennessee last year was a big win. The win in the tourney was St. Mary's BTW, not St Joes.
With the conference being weak the past few years, there hasn't been tons of opportunities to win those games. The team hasn't seen enough of the MSUs, Michigans, etc to gain the confidence they need. This is all partly the coaches fault but I still give him some slack because of his experience.
For 2013 he has two terrific assistant coaches (Robert Kirby and Aki Collins.....third to be named later.....(maybe a Miles Simon type). His recruiting has been great for a team that was left for dead and a team that many high level coaches wouldn't touch when Cal left.
The OOC schedule for '13 is going to be a killer: Louisville, UCONN, Okla St (twice), Gonzaga and Florida should be some of the tougher ones. There's the Old Spice tournament with Butler, LSU, Okla St, Purdue, St Joe's, Siena and Wash St. If Pastner doesn't come away from a few of those with wins, I'll start to worry.