George Halas didn't even make him practice if he did not want to. I think Papa Bear knew some football. Voted the BEST player in the first 50 years of the SEC, unanimously. I rest my case.
To be voted unanimous to anything is an achievement... but to be voted THE BEST unanimously is unheard of. Think of all the great players that played in the SEC from 1950-74. Doug Atkins was considered better than ALL of them. Better than fellow hall-of-famers Jack Youngblood (Florida), Archie Manning (Ole Miss), Babe Parilli (Kentucky), Steve Spurrier (Florida), Pat Sullivan (Auburn), Fran Tarkenton (Georgia), Lee Roy Jordan (Alabama), Johnny Majors (Tennessee), Johnny Musso (Alabama), Frank Emanuel (Tennessee), DD Lewis (Miss State), Hank Lauricella (Tennessee), John Hannah (Alabama), Steve Kiner (Tennessee), Tommy Casanova (LSU), Ozzie Newsome (Alabama), just to name a few.