As I scrolled through the thread, I had the same thoughts as utvolpj. I am not an expert in the scholly limits, but based on what both sides are saying about the limits, it sounds like UGA cannot sign 34.
If the limit is 25, and 25 signed in 2011, and none of them were backcounted to 2010, then none of the 2012 guys can be backcounted to 2011. (perhaps 3 guys in 2011 were backcounted to 2010, and the UGA fan left that part out)