According to Fangraphs WAR, Chipper is the 35th best positional player, high than such names as: Ken Griffey Jr., Reggie Jackson, Al Simmons, Willie McCovey, Derek Jeter, Carlton Fisk, Ernie Banks, and Robin Yount.
No way, Rose was a much better switch hitter than Eddie. I wouldnt even have Eddie as fourth. I would have him fifth behind Mick, Chipper, Rose, and George Davis