Dobbs 4 Heisman
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2015
- Messages
- 16,236
- Likes
- 16,352
Out of the rest above, I'll give you credit for Breida and that's about it. There isn't a lot up there that wasn't already being seen as future stars (Mahomes was pegged to be a stud and right now, the best QB to come through in the past few years, Mixon had all the talent in the world if he can stay out of trouble, McCaffrey was a first round pick for crying out loud, Smith-Schuster was a highly rated second round pick).
I had to isolate this part because of how silly it is. The point of evaluating prospects is to identify who the stars will be. Just because most people also had those guys pegged for stardom doesn't mean I don't get credit for it as well. Many 1st rounders bust. So just because Mahomes, McCaffrey, and Mixon had a lot of hype coming into the league doesn't mean I can't claim to be right if they live up to it. Remember I didn't hype up Fournette and Cook (two other highly regarded prospects). And I've been proven right thus far to not think much of them as they've had disappointing NFL careers. My thing here isn't just that I try to find diamonds in the rough. I'm evaluating all the prospects. And if I co-sign on the highly regarded ones and then they live up to the billing then that is a correct evaluation on my part.
Now onto JuJu Smith-Schuster. He was a highly regarded college player but the NFL draft is different. There's a reason he lasted until LATE in the 2nd round. People questioned his speed and overall athleticism. He was the 6th WR taken in the draft remember. #62 overall. That's almost the 3rd round. During that draft cycle all the talk was about Mike Williams, John Ross, and Corey Davis. Nobody was talking about JuJu Smith-Schuster as an elite prospect but me. To me this is like ya'll trying to dismiss my call about Alvin Kamara simply because some of ya'll thought he would be good in the NFL. None of ya'll thought he would be as good as he's turned out to be but me. If you did, you would have had him rated higher than Fournette and Cook. Similarly, nobody thought JuJu Smith-Schuster would be as good in the NFL as I did. If more people did, then he would have been universally rated as a 1st round prospect and among the top 2 WRs in the draft like I did.