So you admit he's not a good recruiter. I think that's the whole point.
I don’t admit that at all. Mullen’s class is currently ranked 7th on Rivals. How’s that not good with 5 more weeks to go?! Florida had a disappointing early signing day because they whiffed on a few guys they were trying to flip, but this isn’t at all a disappointing class so far. They’ll pick up 3 or 4 more between now and NSD in February and will likely finish somewhere between 5 and 9 in the final rankings. And that will be back-to-back top 8 classes for Mullen. Then you add in what Florida is doing from a facilities standpoint, led by Mullen, and that will only help.
Sometimes UF’s rival fans really compliment Florida when they’re not meaning to. Recruiting is a great example. Only at Florida can two top 8 recruiting classes be classified as “failures” when there are 100+ other schools who would love to trade classes. Only at Florida can fans of a team with a ranking below Florida, actually criticize Florida even though UF’s in front of their own team. Apparently Mullen will be criticized in recruiting until he’s had multiple years in the top three or something (which is coming).
And don’t get me started on the transfer portal as that’s a whole other modern day level of recruiting, and arguably Dan Mullen is the best in the country at landing great players from the portal. Mullen is ahead of the game in this phase of recruiting. Can anyone name a better group of transfer players than this? Van Jefferson - UF’s leading WR last two seasons. Tre Grimes - former 5* and productive WR. Jean Delance - starting RT entire season. Marlon Dunlap - producer on DL. Adam Shuler - two year starter at DT. Brenton Cox - former 5* DE/OLB. Jon Greenard - all-SEC, all-American (cbs) DE. Even the punter, Townsend, came from the portal.
Hang your hat on calling Mullen a bad recruiter while he’s ranked well inside the top 10 if you want, but you’re living a lie. He’s added great players through recruiting and the portal during his 2 years at UF. Would I like to be at #1 in the rankings right now, absolutely. And would I prefer Mullen never miss on a 5*Florida kid like Demarckus Bowman, yes. But am I pleased with Mullen’s overall roster management? Absolutely!